Sunday, 6 February 2022

Archaeology and legend: investigating Stonehenge - Mike Parker Pearson

Archaeology and legend: investigating Stonehenge

RESEARCH-ARTICLE

 1 , 

Archaeology International

UCL Press

Neolithic, Stonehenge, stone circles, Britain, legend


Abstract

Stonehenge is one of the world’s most famous prehistoric monuments, built 4,500–5,000 years ago during the Neolithic in a time long before written history. The recent dramatic discovery of a dismantled stone circle near the sources of some of Stonehenge’s stones in southwest Wales raises the fascinating possibility that an ancient story about Stonehenge’s origin, written down 900 years ago and subsequently dismissed as pure invention, might contain a grain of truth. This article explores the pros and cons of comparing the legend with the archaeological evidence.

Main article text

Introduction

Myths and legends have always inspired archaeologists and adventurers: Homer’s Iliad in the search for Troy; the legend of King Arthur in the search for Camelot; or the Greek myth of Minos and the Minotaur’s labyrinth in the discovery of Knossos. Often the myth proves elusive, as in the fruitless search for Eldorado’s city of gold or the quest for Prester John’s fabled lost kingdom. The complex relationship between archaeology and ancient legend is fraught with difficulties. What legends, if any, may be considered true? Might some contain only a kernel of truth, fortuitously resistant to the erosive sands of time? Or are they merely the vestiges of ever-changing stories from a bygone age that were intended only to entertain and moralise, and not to bear witness?

One of the earliest recorded tales of ancient Britain relates to the building of Stonehenge. Written by Geoffrey of Monmouth in about 1136, just six years or so after the very first documentary reference to Stonehenge by Henry of Huntingdon, it is a lengthy account of how Merlin the wizard organised, on behalf of Aurelius Ambrosius, the building of this great monument – supposedly a memorial for the fallen – by taking megalithic stones from a previous stone circle in Ireland. This story is found in Historia Regum Britanniae (The History of the Kings of Britain, also known as De Gestis Britonum [On the Deeds of the Britons]), written by a cleric, Geoffrey of Monmouth (Galfridus Monemutensis). Although its title seemingly promised an accurate presentation of facts, it can best be described as a pseudo-history in which a few reliable historical facts are sprinkled among a morass of uncorroborated fictions and false claims (Wright 2007). Geoffrey’s work may be better considered as a political statement to demonstrate the unity of Britain rather than an objective historical account (Flood 2016).

Although Geoffrey drew on a number of identifiable historical sources, including Gildas, Bede and supposedly ‘a very old book in the British tongue’, much of his writing is thought to have come from his own imagination. As early as 1190, William of Newburgh was claiming that most of Geoffrey’s history relating to the time of Merlin and King Arthur was made up, partly by Geoffrey and partly by others (Chippindale 1994, 24). The passages that relate to Stonehenge (which he names as Stanheng; Wright 2007, 180) have no antecedent in any earlier writings, so the account’s lack of historical pedigree places it in the category of ‘fake’ history unless proved otherwise. During the twentieth century scholars mused on whether any aspect of it might be true, with varying degrees of confidence in its possible veracity (Hibbard Loomis 1930; Piggott 1941). So why should we pay any attention to this story? What could it contain that might possibly relate to the purpose of Stonehenge? But, first, what does Geoffrey’s story actually say about Stonehenge?

The legend of Merlin and Stonehenge

According to Geoffrey, Stonehenge’s origins lay in a time of conflict between Britons and invading Saxons in the aftermath of Roman rule. During a parlay at ‘Ambrius’ (Amesbury, close to the site of Stonehenge), 460 British aristocrats are treacherously murdered by King Hengist and his Saxons, carrying daggers under their clothes. Sometime later, the British king Aurelius Ambrosius replaces the previous king, Vortigern, unites the armies of Britain and defeats the Saxons. Wanting an everlasting memorial to the Britons killed at Mount Ambrius, he calls upon Merlin to devise a suitable monument. Merlin decrees that it should be built out of Chorea Gigantum (the Dance of the Giants/Giants’ Dance/Giants’ Ring), a circle of enormous stones on the mountain of Killaraus in Ireland. ‘If you set them up in the same pattern around the burial-place, they will stand forever’ (Wright 2007, 172). According to Merlin, they had been erected by giants who used them for their magical and medicinal properties; whenever they fell sick, they set up baths among them, washed the stones and poured the water in the baths to be cured. It is these mystical stones that Merlin wants for his design of Stonehenge.

Merlin and the king’s brother Uther Pendragon take 15,000 men to Ireland, defeat the Irish army and dismantle the stones, shipping them back to England and setting them up around the Britons’ burial place at Mount Ambrius in the same manner as they had been in Ireland. As well as memorialising the British fallen, Stonehenge becomes the burial place first of Aurelius Ambrosius and then Uther Pendragon, father of King Arthur, the heroic war-leader of legend. The final royal burial at Stonehenge is Arthur’s successor Constantinus, supposedly around 542 ce.

There are clearly major impediments to assuming that this story is in any way true. Stonehenge was built in the third millennium bce and not in the 400s ce when Britons fought Saxons. Nor was there an ancient race of giants. And nor do Stonehenge’s stones come from Ireland. Yet there are niggling questions that hint at possible grains of truth buried in this medieval legend. Among the remaining stones of Stonehenge are 43 ‘bluestones’ which derive from the Preseli hills of southwest Wales, 275 km from Salisbury Plain (Figure 1). Might these somehow relate to the legend’s account of a distant origin in Ireland?

Figure 1

Stonehenge’s bluestones (see inset) were brought from the Preseli hills, 275 km from Stonehenge. The sea and coastal routes now seem unlikely with the discovery that one of the stones (the Altar Stone) probably comes from an inland part of South Wales, along the postulated overland route (Source: Irene De Luis)

Of the hundreds of Britain’s stone circles, only Stonehenge is composed of stones that have travelled a great distance. This fact could not have been known before the advent of the modern science of geology. Is it actually possible that knowledge of its distant sources was passed down by word of mouth over some 4,000 years from prehistory to Geoffrey’s time? The question is even more pertinent when we consider that Pembrokeshire, the region of southwest Wales from which the bluestones derive, may well have been considered in the post-Roman and early medieval period to be part of Ireland. Irish kings were believed to have ruled this region in the centuries before Geoffrey’s time, up to the end of the eleventh century (Davies 1982, 87–8, 95; 1990, 39), the area having been settled by the Irish probably from 400 ce onwards (Davies 1982, 88). Yet this attribution is problematic; within a few pages of his story of the Dance of the Giants, Geoffrey talks of St David’s in Pembrokeshire as being in Wales and not Ireland.

While Geoffrey’s identification of Ireland as the source of Stonehenge’s stones may be broadly compatible with the bluestones’ origin in the Preseli hills of Pembrokeshire, there is no evidence for the existence anywhere of a Mount Killaraus (later referred to in William Caxton’s Chronicle of England of 1480 as ‘the mounte of kylyon’; Chippindale 1994, 25). So can the archaeological evidence help us further?

Archaeological evidence

Although antiquarians and archaeologists have studied Stonehenge for over 300 years, it is only recently that much attention has been paid to Geoffrey’s story. In 2008 Timothy Darvill and Geoffrey Wainwright carried out an excavation at Stonehenge, developing their theory that Stonehenge had been built as a place of healing, drawing on one particular aspect of the tale (Darvill and Wainwright 2009, 16–18). They considered the bluestones to have arrived at Stonehenge around or after 2500 bce, linking their presence with nearby burials of people with unusual injuries (Darvill 2007). One of these was the Amesbury Archer, a Beaker migrant of 2480–2280 bce from continental Europe with a damaged knee (Fitzpatrick 2011). Two others were Early Bronze Age people (c. 2000 bce) whose skulls had been trepanned – suffering holes cut into their skulls – perhaps as a cure for illness.

The healing theory is not without problems. Excavations at Stonehenge in 2008 by a second team, the Stonehenge Riverside Project, produced evidence that the bluestones had been erected much earlier, during its first stage in 2995–2900 bce (Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 168, 536), and that the monument had been used as a large cemetery from this time onwards for the next 300–600 years (Parker Pearson et al. 2009; 2020, 539–43; Willis et al. 2016). The burials with unusual injuries were most likely 600–1,000 years later than the arrival of the supposed ‘healing’ bluestones, which had in fact adorned a burial ground – a place of the dead rather than a place of healing. More appropriately, the motive of healing and curing fits well with the medieval ecclesiastical mindset. For example, just a few pages later in his History, Geoffrey twice refers to healing waters in contexts other than the Giants’ Dance (Wright 2007, 115, 116). The claim that water splashed on stones of the Giants’ Dance had healing properties is more likely to be an anachronistic fancy in the same way as the erroneous post-Roman date of Stonehenge.

Darvill and Wainwright had been searching since 2002 for the source of the bluestones in the Preseli hills of southwest Wales, the area identified by the geologist Herbert Thomas a century earlier (Thomas 1923). ‘Bluestone’ is a catch-all term for a variety of Stonehenge’s monoliths, used to distinguish these small pillars from sarsens – the huge silcrete blocks that comprise the majority of Stonehenge’s stones and most likely derive from West Woods, 24 km to the north (Parker Pearson 2016; Nash et al. 2020). Bluestones are actually a variety of rock types: spotted dolerite, unspotted dolerite, rhyolite, volcanics and sandstone. All derive from on and around the Preseli hills except for the sandstone Altar Stone, which comes from an as yet unidentified source (Ixer and Bevins 2011; Bevins et al. 2013, 2020; Ixer et al. 2017).

In 2011 geologists Richard Bevins and Rob Ixer published their identification of an impressive rocky outcrop at Craig Rhos-y-felin, just north of the Preseli hills, as a source of one of the types of rhyolite at Stonehenge (Figure 2). Two years later their geochemical analysis sourced spotted and unspotted dolerite stones from Stonehenge to two less spectacular outcrops in these hills, one at Carn Goedog and the other at Cerrigmarchogion (Bevins, Ixer and Pearce 2013). This was something of a bombshell because, ever since Thomas’s time, archaeologists had been focused on a different location, the impressive outcrop of Carn Menyn or Carn Meini (see, for example, Atkinson 1956, 36–9); yet none of Stonehenge’s bluestones in the new analysis matched the geology of this more prominent outcrop.

Figure 2

Location of the dismantled stone circle of Waun Mawn (red-ringed circle) as well as the bluestone sources of Carn Goedog (spotted dolerite), Craig Rhos-y-felin (rhyolite) and Cerrigmarchogion (unspotted dolerite). The locations of the Neolithic causewayed enclosure of Banc Du and palisaded enclosure of Dryslwyn (black-ringed circles), and Early Neolithic portal tombs (black squares) are also shown (Source: Mike Parker Pearson)

Armed with the geologists’ dramatic discoveries, the Stonehenge Riverside team began investigations of the rhyolite and spotted dolerite sources at Craig Rhos-y-felin and Carn Goedog respectively. For the next five years, as part of the Stones of Stonehenge project, we carried out excavations at the two outcrops. Both sites produced evidence of human activity, from the Mesolithic (8000–4000 bce) to the medieval period, but especially from the Neolithic period in the centuries before and around 3000 bce, just before the installation of bluestones at Stonehenge. This Neolithic evidence included stone tools and quarrying installations – gaps in the rock where pillars had been removed, artificial stone platforms onto which monoliths had been lowered and a trackway leading from the foot of one of the loading platforms (Parker Pearson et al. 2016; Parker Pearson, Bevins et al. 2015; Parker Pearson, Pollard et al. 2017, 2019).

The aims of the Stones of Stonehenge project were to identify the bluestone quarries for Stonehenge and also to find out about the landscape context of these quarries. What was so special about the Preseli area in the Neolithic? It was already known that this region, including the valley of the River Nevern on the north side of the hills, was a focus for Early Neolithic settlement (4000–3400 bce), judging by the concentration of dolmens and enclosures (Lynch 1972; Darvill and Wainwright 2016, 55–76). But what could be associated with the period of the bluestone quarries – the Middle Neolithic between 3400–3000 bce? And why was there seemingly little trace of any activity in the Late Neolithic (3000–2500 bce), the time of Stonehenge?

From 2012 onwards the Stones of Stonehenge project set out to explore the landscape around the bluestone quarries. With most of the agricultural land under permanent pasture, their survey methods included aerial photography, LiDAR (light detection and ranging), three-dimensional aerial photogrammetry and geophysics, coupled with excavation. Although numerous circular enclosures were identified as possible henges, all turned out to be sites of a much later date (Casswell, Comeau and Parker Pearson 2016; Parker Pearson, Caswell and Welham 2017; 2018). It seemed that the project had run out of road, and in 2017 the team members were ready to abandon the quest for Middle Neolithic sites. As a final move, we took a second look at a group of four standing stones on the hill of Waun Mawn, within 5 km of the bluestone quarries (Figure 3).

Figure 3

The arc of former standing stones at Waun Mawn during trial excavations in 2017, viewed from the east. Only one of them (third from the camera) is still standing. The stone in the foreground originally stood in a socket and formed one side of the solstice sunrise-oriented entrance of the former circle (Source: photograph by Adam Stanford)

Waun Mawn: a dismantled stone circle

We had investigated the standing stones of Waun Mawn in 2011, carrying out geophysical surveys around the stones to see if their curving arrangement was due to their being remnants of a mostly demolished stone circle. This had been the interpretation of archaeologists a hundred years before (RCAHMW 1925, 258–9), although later archaeologists, including W.F. Grimes, a director of the Institute of Archaeology, had been sceptical of this interpretation (Grimes 1963, 150; Burl 1976, 371). Disappointingly, our magnetometer and resistivity surveys yielded no trace of buried stoneholes to indicate that the arc of stones had originally formed part of a complete circle. It seemed that ‘Peter’ Grimes had been right to dismiss it.

With a last throw of the dice, we returned to Waun Mawn in 2017, this time with spades and shovels. Excavating beyond the ends of the arc, we uncovered two stoneholes that had once held standing stones, although the stones themselves were long gone. It was clear that the geophysical surveys in 2011 had not worked on the difficult terrain, so in 2018 we brought in teams of geophysicists who tried the full range of methods, including ground-penetrating radar and electromagnetic induction. With no positive results from any of the methods, even where we knew there were stoneholes, it was now clear that the poor magnetic and conductive properties of the underlying glacial drift were contributing to this problem. Geophysical survey was not going to help us, and the only way forward was to try to find more stoneholes by excavation.

We returned to Waun Mawn in September 2021 with a team of staff, volunteers and students from UCL and the universities of Southampton and Bournemouth. In just three weeks of excavation by hand we discovered another four stoneholes, revealing that the surviving stones had indeed once been part of a stone circle 110 m in diameter, making it the third largest stone circle in Britain (Figure 4; Parker Pearson et al. 2021). The stoneholes were not particularly deep, but each bore at its base the imprint of the standing stone that had formerly stood in it. Most also had packing stones – small stone blocks jammed into the ground to stabilise the standing stone – even though the monoliths that originally stood in these holes had been removed.

Figure 4

The excavation trenches (in black [2018] and red [2021]) at Waun Mawn, showing the locations of the four remaining standing stones (in purple), the additional stoneholes (in red), pits that never held stones (in green) and other features (in black). From the centre of the circle, the midsummer solstice sun rose within the entrance formed by Stoneholes 128 and 21 (Source: Chris Casswell and Kate Welham)

Two of the stoneholes were different to the others. These were both on the northeast side of the circle and had no packing stones. Beside one of them was one of the four surviving standing stones, now lying on its side; it had obviously once stood in this hole. What was most unusual about these two stoneholes was the direction of their axis. Instead of having their long sides facing inwards to the centre of the circle, they were perpendicular to it. We realised that this ‘gunsight’ arrangement identified them as opposite sides of an entrance into the circle. Measurements taken by archaeoastronomer Clive Ruggles in 2019 revealed that the entrance faced towards the midsummer solstice sunset, similar to the famous orientation of Stonehenge (Figure 5).

Figure 5

Positions of Waun Mawn’s entrance stones as seen from the centre of the circle. The digitally generated profile shows the path of the rising summer solstice sun around 3300 bce (Source: Clive Ruggles)

A further surprise was our realisation that the diameter of Waun Mawn was the same as the diameter of the enclosing ditch around Stonehenge. As far as we know, no other Neolithic monument in Britain has this same diameter of 110 m (though several fall within the range of 13–100 m). This remarkable coincidence provides a further link between the two circles of Waun Mawn and Stonehenge. Yet the most important question to be answered about their relationship was whether the Waun Mawn circle dated to before Stonehenge (i.e. before 3000 bce) and whether its vanished standing stones had been removed by the time that bluestones were set up at Stonehenge (also probably around or slightly after 3000 bce). Could Waun Mawn have been the original Stonehenge, the Dance of the Giants?

Dating these events of construction and dismantling at Waun Mawn would not be as easy as it might sound. While archaeologists working on prehistory mostly rely on radiocarbon dating, the acidic soils of southwest Wales destroy materials containing carbon, such as bones, wood or antler, except for charcoal. Although common on settlement sites, charcoal is exceedingly sparse on ceremonial sites such as stone circles. Through systematic flotation and fine sieving of the fills of the stoneholes, we recovered a few very small pieces of charred wood. These presented further problems because such small pieces are liable to be either residual (incorporated into the fill of a stonehole having been deposited in the soil centuries or millennia earlier) or intrusive (moved downwards into the stonehole by worm action centuries or millennia later). How could we tell which charcoal pieces dated to the time of the circle’s construction and dismantling and which to before or after?

The way to answer these troubling questions was to employ a second method of dating alongside that of radiocarbon, which was carried out by Tim Kinnaird of the University of St Andrews. This method was optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) profiling and dating, a technique which measures the energy remnant in quartz-grained sediment since it was last exposed to light and estimates the time which has passed since that moment. It is less precise than radiocarbon dating, producing a wide error margin of 10 per cent, which covers the best part of a millennium when dating sediments laid down in the Neolithic. We realised, however, that it could provide broad parameters for the circle’s dates of construction and dismantling.

Stone circles are difficult to date because of the general lack of suitable finds or dating materials. We are fortunate that Stonehenge is so well dated because of surviving antler tools and bones. Yet Britain’s largest stone circle, Avebury, remains undated. Like Stonehenge, some of Britain’s great stone circles date to the early third millennium bce – Calanais in the Outer Hebrides (Ashmore 2016) and the Ring of Brodgar in Orkney (Richards 2013, 90–118). Also in Orkney, the Stones of Stenness are dated to 3020–2890 bce (Schulting et al. 2010, 35–6). The small stone circle later covered by the passage tomb of Bryn Celli Ddu on Anglesey in the north of Wales is associated with cremation burials dating to 3500–3100 bce and 3310–2900 bce (Burrow 2010). Of closely comparable size to Waun Mawn, the circle of Long Meg and her Daughters in Cumbria, 172 km in diameter, is dated to 3340–3100 bce on hazel charcoal from one of its stoneholes (Archaeological Services Durham University 2016). In summary, we can currently date the earliest stone circles to the Middle Neolithic – between 3400 bce and 3000 bce – though they continued to be built throughout the Late Neolithic, with smaller circles constructed during the Copper Age and Bronze Age, continuing well after 2000 bce (Bradley and Nimura 2016).

The OSL dates from packing deposits in Waun Mawn’s stoneholes can be combined to produce a weighted probable date of construction of 3530±330 bce (3860–3200 bce). Sediments from the fills of the empty sockets provide a weighted probable date of dismantling before 2120±520 bce (2640–1600 bce). This latter date, of course, may be much later than the actual date of dismantling since it is derived from sediments that filled the voids left by the removed stones. While this removal is likely to have taken place in the Neolithic, we cannot say just when.

Thirty-one radiocarbon dates on charcoal from Waun Mawn’s stoneholes range from the Mesolithic to the Iron Age, although none fall within the Late Neolithic (3000–2500 bce) or Copper Age (2500–2200 bce). Only four coincide with the OSL dates for construction: 3670–3520 bce, 3650–3520 bce, 3500–3340 bce and 3340–3030 bce. The two dating methods together suggest that the Waun Mawn stone circle was constructed in 3400–3200 bce. The date of 3340–3030 bce is from charcoal within an emptied socket, so could provide a date for removal of the standing stone.

With further analysis ongoing to see if the dating of Waun Mawn can be refined, the current evidence reveals that Waun Mawn was left unfinished, abandoned in mid-construction, since holes were prepared for stones that they never held (see Figure 4). Of the standing stones that were put up, all but four were then dismantled, perhaps taken to Salisbury Plain to be erected in Stonehenge’s first stage which began in 3080–2950 bce (Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 164). There is a strong case that can be made for Stonehenge as a second-hand monument, constructed in its first stage out of bluestones that had graced Waun Mawn. Since the likely number of stones that once stood at Waun Mawn is unlikely to have numbered more than 15, based on the positions of stoneholes, it is most likely that other bluestones either came direct from the quarries or derived from other, as yet undiscovered, stone circles in the Preseli area.

The Dance of the Giants?

There is the possibility that Waun Mawn could be the site of the Dance of the Giants. Its elevated location at 331 m OD on a high hill within the Preselis could qualify as a ‘mountain’. The concordance of the stone circle’s diameter, comparable to Stonehenge’s Stage 1 enclosing ditch, echoes Geoffrey’s words: ‘erected … round the cemetery exactly as they had stood on Mount Killaraus in Ireland’. Yet other features do not coincide. Waun Mawn shows no sign of any ‘baths’ for collecting water among the stones; perhaps this section of the narrative was entirely invented to provide some justification for the medieval mind of why the stones were so important that they had to be moved such an extraordinary distance. At the very best, the legend may preserve only the fact that there was a stone circle in the far west dismantled and moved to Stonehenge, and that Stonehenge was a memorial to the dead as demonstrated by its use as a cemetery.

More can be said about the motivation behind the bluestones’ movement. The legend’s account of the stones being forcibly taken is contradicted by recent evidence of mobility among those buried at Stonehenge. Strontium isotope analysis of cremated bone can establish movement between geological zones by an individual in the last decades of their lifetime (during the continuous process of bone remodelling). Analysis of 25 cremated individuals from Stonehenge has revealed that at least ten lived beyond the chalk of Salisbury Plain, four on geology consistent with that of southwest Wales (Snoeck et al. 2018). Interestingly, these four women and men are among the first people to have been buried at Stonehenge (since the latest of them dates to 3020–2900 bce). Since Stonehenge’s burials are likely to number 150 or more, these 4 out of 25 can be extrapolated to represent perhaps around 30 people of this external origin buried there. Since bone remodels within a decade or so to absorb the strontium isotope ratios of the underlying geology, any incomers who died more than a decade after moving would not show up by this method. Taking this possibility into account, perhaps as many as half of the people buried at Stonehenge could have been incomers; the 4 out of 25 thus potentially represent an initial migration, followed by their descendants living locally on and around the chalklands of the Stonehenge area.

This pattern of movement among the people of Stonehenge suggests that some came with the bluestones, that the stones were brought by the Neolithic inhabitants of Preseli and not taken by the invading force of a Neolithic Uther Pendragon. Just like the healing explanation, the story of seizure of the stones may also be erroneous. A new avenue of investigation is the possibility that the paucity of evidence for Late Neolithic activity in Preseli may represent a real pattern of out-migration around 3000 bce.

Finally, one further aspect of the legend is of interest. The Neolithic people of Wales and western Britain can be differentiated from those of southeast England on the basis of both material culture (see, for example, Pioffet 2017) and genetic ancestry (Brace et al. 2019). This potential territorial separation between east and west, with Salisbury Plain in the borderland in between, echoes Geoffrey’s anachronistic conflict between Saxons of the east and Britons of the west, meeting at a place of parlay. Given Stonehenge’s location at a place that already had a tradition in the Neolithic of large-scale gatherings for feasting and monument building, its purpose may have been as a monument of unification (Childe 1957, 331; Gron et al. 2018; Parker Pearson 2012, 2019; Parker Pearson, Pollard et al. 2015; Parker Pearson et al. 2020). Its location between large-scale territorial groupings to the east and west may have enhanced its significance as a place of conflict resolution where groups from different regions could meet to resolve their differences. Perhaps Stonehenge really was erected in its first stage by ‘Britons’ (people in the west, as opposed to ‘Saxons’ – people of the east) to commemorate a disastrous and bloody parlay gone wrong.

The antipathy of resident Britons and incoming Saxons can also be read as another anachronistic reworking of a second prehistoric encounter, this time around 2500 bce, when the second stage of Stonehenge involved the erection of the great sarsens as a horseshoe of five trilithons surrounded by a circle of lintelled sarsens. This major rebuilding of Stonehenge, when it took the form that it largely has today, took place on the eve of the arrival of new practices from the Continent. Recent genetic analysis of ancient DNA has revealed that the people introducing new rites of inhumation burial accompanied by a pot and other grave goods – the so-called Beaker people – have genetic ancestries distinct from the Neolithic population of Britain (Olalde et al. 2018). Although the earliest Beaker burials date to 2450–2325 bce (Jay et al. 2019, 75), it is very possible that the first Beaker people arrived in Britain in earlier decades in a ‘contact’ scenario that has left few archaeological traces. It is just possible that the legend preserves a folk memory of this event, the outcome of which was to be as transformative of prehistoric society as the Saxons’ invasion was for early medieval England.

Conclusion: the longevity of oral tradition

The various concordances between legend and reality at Stonehenge might be entirely dismissed as no more than coincidence if we can be certain that oral traditions have little or no chance of lasting 4,000 years. An acceptable limit would seem to be 500 years in many cases (Parker Pearson 2012, 280). Homer’s Iliad is thought to have been composed around 700 bce, drawing on oral history of events that took place 500 years earlier. In traditional societies today, such as in southern Madagascar and Highland New Guinea, it is possible that some oral traditions also go back as far as 500 years (Parker Pearson et al. 1999; Weissner and Tumu 1998). On the Pacific island of Vanuatu, the memory of Chief Roy Mata has persisted for nearly 800 years (Garanger 1972). An even older oral history of coastal abandonment by the Tsimshian of the Pacific Northwest region of British Columbia has been corroborated by simulation-based modelling of radiocarbon dating, placing this event 1,200–1,100 years ago (Edinborough et al. 2017).

Greater claims are made for India’s oldest Sanskrit texts, the Vedas. These are reckoned to have originated in the Late Bronze Age, around 1000 bce, and to have been transmitted orally over a period of some 3,000 years (Gerety 2017). There are even claims for oral history dating back 10,000 years or more, relating to sea-level changes on the northwest coast of North America (McLaren et al. 2015, 161–2). Australian Aboriginal oral tradition relating to ancient flood events has been claimed as evidence of transmitted memory of early Holocene sea-level rise some 7,000 years ago (Nunn 2018).

In a worldwide survey of deep-time oral traditions, David Henige (2009) points out many of the problems of trying to tie oral history to ancient geological events that occurred many thousands of years ago. The two cases of sea-level rise just mentioned are examples of the many flood myths found in different cultures throughout the world and which need not have any basis in reality. According to Henige, such claims for deep-time transmission of oral histories are, in the words of his article’s title, ‘impossible to disprove but impossible to believe’.

Scholars … can assume that indeed oral traditions can be, and often are, transmitted intact as many as hundreds of times, immune to internal and external influences all along the way. Or they can assume instead that during the course of these transmissions many influences affected and changed the content of these traditions, ending with the incorporation of outside matter ... Given these two mutually exclusive choices, it seems impossible to choose the first. (Henige 2009, 226)

We should further consider that the British situation is likely to have differed from these cases drawn from Australia, Vanuatu, the pre-Colombian Americas and elsewhere. While these can be characterised as Indigenous cultures with long-term continuities of tradition, there is evidence for substantial cultural and population discontinuity across the last four millennia of Britain’s prehistory and early history, starting with the arrival of the Beaker people in the mid-third millennium bce (Olalde et al. 2018; Parker Pearson, Sheridan et al. 2019). We have to conclude that, in the case of Stonehenge, an oral tradition surviving from around 3000–2500 bce until the twelfth century ce is most probably beyond the limits of survivable transmission.

Archaeology’s long-term relationship with folkloric studies has diverged in the last few decades, despite the need for collaboration between disciplines (Paphitis 2013). For the time being, at least, we have to keep the legend separate from the archaeological evidence, even though, as the archaeologist Stuart Piggott observed long ago, they have intriguing points of correspondence which may just be too remarkable to be dismissed as mere coincidence (Piggott 1941, 306). On the one hand, Geoffrey’s tale cannot be used to ‘flesh out’ the bones of the archaeological story. Yet on the other – just maybe – aspects of the legend might help us peer into the vanished world of prehistory.

Acknowledgements

Thanks are due to the Barony of Cemaes, Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru (Natural Resources Wales) and the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park for permissions to excavate at Waun Mawn. The excavations and research in 2017, 2018 and 2021 were funded by the Gerda Henkel Stiftung (grant Nos: AZ 11/V/17, AZ 08/V/18 & AZ 66/V/19), the Rust Family Foundation, the NERC Radiocarbon Panel and Raw-Cut TV. The field project was co-directed with Josh Pollard, Colin Richards and Kate Welham, with help from Richard Bevins (geology), Chris Casswell (excavation), Kevan Edinborough (radiocarbon dating), Rob Ixer (geology), Tim Kinnaird (OSL dating), Clive Ruggles (astronomy), Jim Rylatt (excavation), Dave Shaw (excavation), Ellen Simmons (charred wood analysis) and Adam Stanford (aerial photography). Finally, I thank the two anonymous reviewers for their insightful comments which have helped substantially to improve the initial draft.

Conflict of interests

The author declares no conflicts of interest with this work.

References

  1. Archaeological Services Durham University. 2016. Long Meg and her daughters, Little Salkeld, Cumbria: post-excavation full analysis. https://altogetherarchaeology.org/ReportsandProposalDocs/LongMeg/LongMegFA4043.pdf

  2. Ashmore P. 2016. Calanais: Survey and excavation, 1979–88. Edinburgh: Historic Environment Scotland. https://www.historicenvironment.scot/archives-and-research/publications/publication/?publicationId=b6aee5fd-5980-4872-a2e0-a63c00cc7b68

  3. Atkinson RJC. 1956. Stonehenge. London: Hamish Hamilton.

  4. Bevins RE, Ixer RA, Pearce N. 2013. Carn Goedog is the likely major source of Stonehenge doleritic bluestones: Evidence based on compatible element geochemistry and principal components analysis. Journal of Archaeological Science. Vol. 42:179–93

  5. Bevins RE, Pirrie D, Ixer RA, O’Brien H, Parker Pearson M, Power M, Shail R. 2020. Constraining the provenance of the Stonehenge “Altar Stone”: Evidence from automated mineralogy and U–Pb zircon age dating. Journal of Archaeological Science. 120[Cross Ref]

  6. Brace S, Diekmann Y, Booth TJ, Faltyskova Z, Rohland N, Mallick S, Ferry M, Michel M, Oppenheimer J, Broomandkhoshbacht N, et al.. 2019. Ancient genomes indicate population replacement in Early Neolithic Britain. Nature: Ecology and Evolution. Vol. 3(5):765–71

  7. Bradley RJ, Nimura C. 2016. The Use and Reuse of Stone Circles: Fieldwork at five Scottish monuments and its implications. Oxford: Oxbow.

  8. Burl A. 1976. The Stone Circles of the British Isles. New Haven: Yale University Press.

  9. Burrow S. 2010. Bryn Celli Ddu passage tomb, Anglesey: Alignment, construction, date and ritual. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society. Vol. 76:249–70

  10. Casswell C, Comeau R, Parker Pearson M. 2016. An early medieval cemetery and circular enclosure at Felindre Farchog, north Pembrokeshire. Archaeology in Wales. Vol. 56:100–6

  11. Childe VG. 1957. The Dawn of European Civilization. 6th edition. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

  12. Chippindale C. 1994. Stonehenge Complete. 2nd edition. London: Thames & Hudson.

  13. Darvill TC. 2007. Towards the within: Stonehenge and its purposeCult in Context: Reconsidering Ritual in Archaeology. Barraclough DA, Malone C. p. 148–57. Oxford: Oxbow.

  14. Darvill TC, Wainwright GJ. 2009. Stonehenge excavations 2008. Antiquaries Journal. Vol. 89:1–19

  15. Darvill TC, Wainwright GJ. 2016. Neolithic and Bronze Age PembrokeshirePrehistoric, Roman and Early Medieval Pembrokeshire. Pembrokeshire County History, Volume I. p. 55–222. Haverfordwest: Pembrokeshire County History Trust.

  16. Davies W. 1982. Wales in the Early Middle Ages. Leicester: Leicester University Press.

  17. Davies W. 1990. Patterns of Power in Early Wales. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

  18. Edinborough K, Porcˇic´ M, Martindale A, Brown TJ, Supernant K, Ames KM. 2017. Radiocarbon tests for demographic events in written and oral history. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Vol. 114:12436–41

  19. Fitzpatrick AP. 2011. The Amesbury Archer and the Boscombe Bowmen: Bell Beaker burials at Boscombe Down, Amesbury, Wiltshire. Oxford: Oxbow.

  20. Flood N. 2016. Prophecy, Politics and Place in Medieval England: From Geoffrey of Monmouth to Thomas of Erceldoune. Woodbridge: D.S. Brewer.

  21. Garanger J. 1972. ArchĂ©ologie des Nouvelles-HĂ©brides: Contribution Ă  la connaissance desĂ®les du Centre. Paris: ORSTOM.

  22. Grimes WF. 1963. The stone circles and related monuments of WalesCulture and Environment: Essays in honour of Sir Cyril Fox. Foster I, Alcock L. p. 93–152. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

  23. Gron KJ, Rowley-Conwy P, Fernandez-Dominguez E, Gröcke DR, Montgomery J, Nowell GM, Patterson WP. 2018. A meeting in the forest: Hunters and farmers at the Coneybury “anomaly”, Wiltshire. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society. Vol. 84:111–44

  24. Gerety FMM. 2017. Vedic oral traditionOxford Bibliographies on Hinduism. Coleman T. New York: Oxford University Press. [Cross Ref]

  25. Henige D. 2009. Impossible to disprove but impossible to believe: The unforgiving epistemology of deep-time oral tradition. History in Africa. Vol. 36:127–234

  26. Hibbard Loomis L. 1930. Geoffrey of Monmouth and Stonehenge. PMLA. Vol. 45:400–15

  27. Ixer RA, Bevins RE. 2011. Craig Rhos-y-felin, Pont Saeson is the dominant source of the Stonehenge rhyolitic “debitage”. Archaeology in Wales. Vol. 50:21–32

  28. Ixer RA, Turner P, Molyneux S, Bevins RE. 2017. The petrography, geological age and distribution of the Lower Palaeozoic Sandstone debitage from the Stonehenge landscape. Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine. Vol. 110:1–16

  29. Jay M, Richards MP, Marshall P. 2019. Radiocarbon dates and their Bayesian modellingThe Beaker People: Isotopes, mobility and diet in prehistoric Britain. Parker Pearson M, Sheridan A, Jay M, Chamberlain A, Richards MP, Evans J. p. 42–80. Oxford: Oxbow.

  30. Lynch FM. 1972. Portal dolmens in the Nevern valley, PembrokeshirePrehistoric Man in Wales and the West. Lynch FM, Burgess C. p. 67–84. Bath: Adams & Dart.

  31. McLaren D, Rahemtulla F, Gitla (White) E, Fedje D. 2015. Prerogatives, sea level, and the strength of persistent places: Archaeological evidence for long-term occupation of the central coast of British Columbia. BC Studies. Vol. 187:155–91

  32. Nash D, Ciborowski TJR, Ullyot JS, Parker Pearson M, Darvill T, Greaney S, Maniatis G, Whitaker KA. 2020. Origins of the sarsen megaliths at Stonehenge. Science Advances. Vol. 6:[Cross Ref]

  33. Nunn P. 2018. The Edge of Memory: Ancient stories, oral tradition and the post-glacial world. London: Bloomsbury.

  34. Olalde I, Brace S, Allentoft M, Armit I, Kristiansen K, Rohland N, Mallick S, Booth T, SzĂ©csĂ©nyi-Nagy A, Altena E, et al.. 2018. The Beaker phenomenon and the genomic transformation of northwest Europe. Nature. Vol. 555(7695):190–6

  35. Paphitis T. 2013. “Have you come to take the king away?”: A survey of archaeology and folklore in context. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology. Vol. 23: [Cross Ref]

  36. Parker Pearson M. 2012. Stonehenge: Exploring the greatest Stone Age mystery. London: Simon & Schuster.

  37. Parker Pearson M. 2016. The sarsen stones of Stonehenge. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association. Vol. 127:363–9

  38. Parker Pearson M. 2019. Stonehenge’s bluestonesMining and Quarrying in Neolithic Europe: A social perspective. Teather A, Topping P, Baczkowski J. p. 83–100. Oxford: Oxbow.

  39. Parker Pearson M, Bevins RE, Ixer RA, Pollard J, Richards C, Welham K, Chan B, Edinborough K, Hamilton D, Macphail R, et al.. 2015. Craig Rhos-y-felin: A Welsh bluestone megalith quarry for Stonehenge. Antiquity. Vol. 89:1331–52

  40. Parker Pearson M, Casswell C, Welham K. 2017. Excavations at Castell Mawr Iron Age hillfort, Pembrokeshire. Archaeologia Cambrensis. Vol. 166:141–73

  41. Parker Pearson M, Casswell C, Welham K. 2018. A Late Bronze Age ring-fort at Bayvil Farm, north Pembrokeshire. Archaeologia Cambrensis. Vol. 167:113–41

  42. Parker Pearson M, Chamberlain A, Jay M, Marshall P, Pollard J, Richards C, Thomas J, Tilley C, Welham K. 2009. Who was buried at Stonehenge? Antiquity. Vol. 83:23–39

  43. Parker Pearson M, Godden K, Ramilisonina R, Schwenninger J-L, Smith H. 1999. Lost kingdoms: Oral histories, travellers’ tales and archaeology in southern MadagascarHistorical Archaeology: Back from the edge. Funari P, Hall M, Jones S. p. 233–54. London: Routledge.

  44. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Schlee D, Welham K. 2016. In search of the Stonehenge quarries. British Archaeology. Vol. 146:16–23

  45. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Thomas J, Tilley C, Welham K. 2020. Stonehenge for the Ancestors. Part 1: Landscape and monuments. Leiden: Sidestone Press.

  46. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Thomas J, Welham K. 2015. Stonehenge: Making sense of a prehistoric mystery. York: CBA.

  47. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Welham K. 2017. The origins of Stonehenge: On the track of the bluestones. Archaeology International. Vol. 20:54–9

  48. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Welham K, Casswell C, Shaw D, Simmons E, Stanford A, Bevins RE, Ixer RA. 2019. Megalithic quarries for Stonehenge’s bluestones. Antiquity. Vol. 93:45–62

  49. Parker Pearson M, Pollard J, Richards C, Welham K, Kinnaird T, Shaw D, Simmons E, Stanford A, Bevins RE, Ixer RA, et al.. 2021. The original Stonehenge? A dismantled stone circle in the Preseli hills of west Wales. Antiquity. 95

  50. Parker Pearson M, Sheridan A, Jay M, Chamberlain A, Richards MP, Evans J. 2019. The Beaker People: Isotopes, mobility and diet in prehistoric Britain. Oxford: Oxbow.

  51. Piggott S. 1941. The sources of Geoffrey of Monmouth: II. The Stonehenge story. Antiquity. Vol. 15:305–19

  52. Pioffet H. 2017. Societies and identities during the Early Neolithic of Britain and Ireland in their west European context: Characterisation and comparative analyses of pottery production between Channel, Irish Sea and North Sea. Past. Vol. 87:5–7

  53. RCAHMW. 1925. An Inventory of the Ancient Monuments in Wales and Monmouthshire. Volume VII, County of Pembroke. London: HMSO.

  54. Richards C. 2013. Building the Great Stone Circles of the North. Oxford: Windgather.

  55. Schulting RJ, Sheridan JA, Crozier R, Murphy E. 2010. Revisiting Quanterness: New AMS dates and stable isotope data from an Orcadian chamber tomb. Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. Vol. 140:1–50

  56. Snoeck CJ, Pouncett J, Claeys P, Goderis S, Mattielli N, Parker Pearson M, Willis C, Zazzo A, Lee-Thorp J, Schulting R. 2018. Strontium isotope analysis on cremated human remains from Stonehenge support links with west Wales. Scientific Reports. Vol. 8(10790)

  57. Thomas HH. 1923. The source of the stones of Stonehenge. Antiquaries Journal. Vol. 3:239–60

  58. Weissner P, Tumu A. 1998. Historical Vines: Enga networks of exchange, ritual, and warfare in Papua New Guinea. Bathurst: Crawford House.

  59. Willis C, Marshall P, McKinley JI, Pitts M, Pollard J, Richards C, Richards J, Thomas J, Waldron T, Welham K, Parker Pearson M. 2016. The dead of Stonehenge. Antiquity. Vol. 90:337–56

  60. Wright N. 2007. Geoffrey of Monmouth: The history of the kings of Britain. Reeve Michael D. De gestis Britonum [Historia regum BritanniaeWoodbridge: Boydell and Brewer.

Author and article information

Journal
ai
Archaeology International
UCL Press (UK )
2048-4194
30 December 2021
: 24
: 1
: 144-164
Affiliations
[1 ]UCL Institute of Archaeology, UK
Author notes
Article
10.14324/111.444.ai.2021.09
72185a6e-98d0-4033-8fb0-6d7c55147ea2
Copyright © 2021, Mike Parker Pearson

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (CC BY) 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. 

Friday, 28 January 2022

Bluestone transport theory wrecked?

 The Daily Express brings us exciting news of the discovery of a possible Dolerite boulder stuck in the intertidal rocks on the Gower Peninsular.

This blog prides itself on being evidence led and this discovery shades my prefered Bluestone transport theory, the overland A40 route. I freely admit that my preference for this to the Atkinson favoured sea route is because I'm a confirmed landlubber but it also seems to fit the evidence better.

So Phil Holden's discovery of a pillar shaped and sized dolerite, it almost look shaped ready for final dressing, (pictures in the Daily Express) on the coast behoves me to note that it provides good evidence for the rafting of the bluestones around the coast. 

The Gower Peninsula and shipwrecks have become synonymous with each other over the centuries and the discovery of what appears to be the remains of a neolithic cargo driven onto the rocks is exciting but probably not conclusive evidence that this was the route used. No mystery solved, no smoking gun but another piece of the jigsaw as to how the bluestones were transported.

http://www.gowershipwrecks.co.uk/2009/10/gower-shipwreck-wittezee-overton-mere.html



Wednesday, 12 January 2022

Waun Mawn and Gernos-fach: the Welsh origins of Stonehenge project Interim report of the 2021 season

By kind permission of Mike Parker Pearson:

 Waun Mawn and Gernos-fach: the Welsh origins of Stonehenge project Interim report of the 2021 season 

By Mike Parker Pearson, Chris Casswell, Jim Rylatt, Adam Stanford, Kate Welham and Josh  Pollard 

Waun Mawn unfinished stone circle, looking east towards the Preseli ridge. The positions of  the circle’s stoneholes, standing stones and marking-out pits are indicated by people  standing around the circle’s perimeter 

Background 

One of the great mysteries of prehistory is why Stonehenge’s ‘bluestones’ came from over  140 miles away in west Wales. While all but two of Stonehenge’s sarsen stones are now  identified as coming from West Woods, 15 miles to the north, the smaller bluestones  (mostly weighing 1-4 tons) came from the Preseli hills of west Wales. Our aim is to find out  why Stonehenge was built of stones from such distant sources. 

Over the last ten years, the Stones of Stonehenge project has identified and excavated two  of the outcrops from which bluestones were quarried in c.3300-2920 BC, before these  megaliths were erected at Stonehenge in its first stage in c.3000-2920 BC. Archaeologists  and geologists have hypothesised that Stonehenge’s bluestones might have first been  erected as a stone circle in west Wales, that was later dismantled and moved to Salisbury  Plain, rather than being brought directly from their quarries.

Archaeological excavations at the partial stone circle at Waun Mawn in 2017 and 2018  uncovered stone holes of two of its four remaining monoliths and revealed 12 further  features extending beyond the ends of the arc of monoliths. Six of these were holes for  standing stones removed in antiquity. Radiocarbon and optically stimulated luminescence  (OSL) dating places their erection at Waun Mawn in 3400-3200 BC and their dismantling  before 2120±520 BC (i.e. most likely during the Neolithic). 

Together with the four remaining monoliths at Waun Mawn, the six stoneholes excavated in  2018 form part of a former stone circle with a diameter of c.110m. This makes Waun Mawn  the third largest stone circle known in Britain. The largest of the stoneholes had an unusual  pentagonal-shaped base which can be matched with Stone 62 at Stonehenge and contained  

flakes of dolerite that appear to have become detached from the monolith that stood at  Waun Mawn; it is of the same type of rock as that of Stone 62 at Stonehenge.  Further links with Stonehenge are provided by Waun Mawn’s entrance facing midsummer  solstice sunrise and by the diameter of Waun Mawn circle being the same as the diameter  of Stonehenge’s perimeter ditch. 

Waun Mawn is part of a major ceremonial complex within Preseli, including a Neolithic  causewayed enclosure at Banc Du, a Neolithic palisaded enclosure at Dryslwyn, and seven  local Neolithic tombs. This provides a new insight into the significance of the source of  Stonehenge’s bluestones, and raises interesting new questions about the relationship of this  complex with that on Salisbury Plain, such as why some of Stonehenge’s bluestones might  have come from one or more previous monuments in Preseli. One of these other  monuments might be the smaller (45m-diameter) embanked circle of Gernos-fach, 800m  northwest of Waun Mawn. 

Figure 1. Locations of Waun Mawn, Gernos-fach and other Neolithic sites including dolmens  (black squares), enclosures (black circles) and Stonehenge-linked bluestone sources (red  dots) as well as Gernos-Fach circle and the Penlan Stones

Research objectives in 2021 

The project’s ninth field season continued excavations at Waun Mawn (SN 0835 3398) and  began excavations at an embanked circle at Gernos-fach (SN 0770 3452). Geophysical  survey at the pair of Penlan standing stones south of Carnedd Meibion-Owen (SN 0901  3575) was also conducted but failed to identify any features other than the two monoliths. 

The aims of excavation in 2021 of the incomplete stone circle at Waun Mawn were to: 1. Establish the completeness of this former stone circle, to estimate whether it held  more than the 10 standing stones so far detected by their surviving stoneholes. 2. Refine the date of this monument, through further OSL and radiocarbon-dating of  materials within its stone holes. 

3. Explore the centre of the former stone circle to find out whether this was already a  special location when the circle was built and whether a hole survives for a marking-out post  to establish the circle’s radius. 

The proximity of Gernos-fach to Waun Mawn just half a mile away has raised the possibility  that it is of equivalent date to Waun Mawn (i.e. Middle Neolithic) and might have been  similarly dismantled in prehistory to provide bluestones for Stonehenge. 

The aims of the 2021 excavation of Gernos-fach embanked circle were to: 1. Establish when and how it was constructed. 

2. Establish whether its encircling bank originally held a number of standing stones and,  if so, when these were removed. 

3. Establish the positions and forms of the circle’s entrances and whether they were  oriented towards significant astronomical alignments. 

Waun Mawn: an unfinished and dismantled stone circle 

Excavation of the centre of Waun Mawn’s circle revealed the presence of a fireplace within  a small bowl-shaped hearth located 0.70m from the circle’s precise centre (as estimated in  2018). Although this was not the hypothesised hole for a marking-out post (see aim 3  above), it is potentially far more significant in that the wood charcoal in its fill may provide  an even more secure and precise date than that already obtained for the circle’s  construction. The hearth was covered by disturbed sediment from the fall of a large tree.  This raises the possibility that this tree was the visible marker at the circle’s centre, from  which its radius of 55m was measured. As a potentially long-lived landmark, the tree – likely  to be isolated and prominent, given the lack of evidence for similarly large trees across all  the Waun Mawn trenches – could have been an enduring feature in the prehistoric  landscape. The variable distances from this central point to the stoneholes – up to 5m in  some cases – imply that measuring was conducted by pacing rather than with a rope of  fixed length.  

Excavations around the circle’s perimeter confirmed that two extensive arcs in the south  and west had been largely or entirely devoid of stoneholes for since-removed standing  stones. While there was no further trace of any features on the west side, the southern arc  produced a further three or possibly four features which followed the circle’s circumference  but had never held standing stones. These are interpreted as marking-out pits for standing 

stones that were never erected. Two of them, when viewed from the centre of the circle,  are aligned on Carn Goedog (a bluestone quarry) and Foel Feddau (a summit on the Preseli  ridge). This suggests that their positioning within the circle’s perimeter was sighted through  from the centre. An additional such ‘marking-out’ pit on this southern arc was excavated in 2018 and dates to the period of the circle’s construction. 

Figure 2. The hearth at the centre of Waun Mawn stone circle, excavated by Geraint Lloyd 

On the east side, a new stonehole was found in 2021, forming the eastern end of an arc of  four surviving standing stones and six additional stoneholes that extends for almost 100m  from the furthest of these in the circle’s northwest. The presence of a ‘marking-out’ pit just  9m from the eastern terminal of this arc suggests that it was at this very point that  construction of the circle was abandoned.  

Figure 3. The ‘marking-out’ pit beyond the last stonehole in the eastern arc, indicative of the  stone circle’s non-completion (the two small holes within the pit are the result of OSL  sampling)

Reinvestigation of the small recumbent stone forming the left hand side of the midsummer  solstice-oriented entrance revealed that the pit identified in 2018 as its stonehole was in  fact a later feature cut against the west side of the stone’s original stonehole. An interesting  discovery here was a posthole directly adjacent to the northeast end of the stonehole.  Together with a similar posthole detected in 2018 in the southwest end of the stonehole  forming the right side of this entrance, the posts provide evidence for laying out the  midsummer solstice-facing entrance with posts. Presumably this was done before the  standing stones were erected though only the right hand stonehole preserved evidence that the posthole was inserted before the stonehole. These are the only two stoneholes, out of  ten excavated instances, with accompanying postholes. 

Figure 4. The posthole (right) and stonehole for the stone (top right) originally forming the  left hand side of Waun Mawn’s midsummer solstice sunrise-facing entrance 

The only stoneholes detected outside of the circle’s northwest to eastern arc were two on  its southwest perimeter. One of these was excavated in 2018 and a second one, 5.5m to its  west, was investigated in 2021. This proved to be the only stonehole at Waun Mawn found  to have been filled immediately after its standing stone was withdrawn. Its empty socket  was filled with two layers of sediment, the upper one containing a stack of flat stones that  formed a sturdy base for a large dolerite slab laid on top of it and whose lip extended over  the top of these flat stones. Like all other stoneholes at Waun Mawn, this one’s ramp lay on  the side opposite the centre of the circle, indicating that the standing stone had been  extracted in that direction. The position and secure bedding of the large slab would have  enabled it to be used as a rigid fulcrum to lever out the base of the standing stone once it  had been toppled. Its imprint in the bottom of the pit revealed this to have been a  substantial monolith, 0.45m-0.50m in basal cross-section. 

Excavations to either side of this pair of stoneholes in the southwest revealed no further  stoneholes, suggesting that they formed an isolated pair. Viewed from the centre of the  circle, they align not to midwinter solstice sunset (to the east of them) but to where the sun 

sets a month or so before and after midwinter. They do not appear to mark or frame any  significant topographic feature on the horizon. 

Figure 5. The large slab placed over the top of a stonehole on the southwestern perimeter of  Waun Mawn stone circle 

On and around the position of midwinter solstice sunset along the circle’s perimeter, a  concentration of stone tools included artefacts of flint (four scrapers, an oblique arrowhead,  a serrated knife and six flakes) and quartz (eight flakes and two cores), a large dolerite flake  and a circular, trimmed mudstone disc. Near the centre of this concentration, a small setting of flat stones may be the remains of a humanly-made structure. The oblique arrowhead is of  a type in use in Britain between 3400 BC and 2400 BC. Other finds from around the circle’s  perimeter consisted of two circular discs and a quartz core in the east, a quartz bifacial knife  in the south and a flint blade in the west. 

Figure 6. An oblique arrowhead from the southwest perimeter of Waun Mawn stone circle

In summary, the 2021 excavations provide evidence that only 30% of Waun Mawn’s stone  circle was ever completed, leaving large gaps on the west and south sides. Features along  the southern perimeter can be identified as holes that were dug but never held stones,  revealing that building of the circle stopped in mid-construction. Eight standing stones were  subsequently dismantled, leaving just four in place. It is unlikely that there were ever more  than 17 stones erected within this circle, resulting in between eight and 13 being taken  away in prehistory. It is possible but unlikely that there was another dismantled circle within  the larger, 110m-diameter circle; early stone circles of this type, such as Stanton Drew, tend  to have smaller circles beyond them and not inside them. In these circumstances, if Waun  Mawn provided some of the bluestones for Stonehenge, these can only have been a small  portion of the total. 

Figure 7. Plan of trenches (black lines 2017-2018; red lines 2021) showing stoneholes (red),  remaining stones (purple), pits (green) and other features (black) excavated at Waun Mawn

Gernos-fach: an embanked stone circle 

Half a mile to the northwest of Waun Mawn, excavations at Gernos-fach, an embanked  stone circle 45m in diameter, consisted of three trenches. The main one was positioned on  the circle’s dilapidated eastern bank, with smaller trenches over the northern part of the  bank (where the bank was better preserved) and within the circle’s centre.  

Figure 8. The three trenches at Gernos-fach embanked stone circle during deturfing. North is to the  left 

The circle’s enclosing bank contained two dolerite standing stones, one of them leaning and  the other small and stumpy. Whilst the stumpy stone is probably a late addition, inserted as  part of a medieval rectangular structure possibly the remains of a sheepfold, the leaning  stone may well be an original element of the circle though it could have been re-set and its  packing fills disturbed. This unspotted dolerite pillar, over 2.10m long, is unweathered on  one side, likely to be the result of its lying on the ground before erection; it is not a quarried  monolith like so many of the bluestones. Its relationship to the bank could not be  determined with certainty because of erosion of the bank around it. However, about 5m to  its north lay an empty stonehole, also positioned centrally beneath the spine of the bank.  This had held a standing stone before the bank was constructed. This eastern arc of bank  had been robbed of much of its stone, quite probably in the medieval period, leaving a layer  of sediment and stones that sealed the stonehole. The fill of this stonehole’s empty socket  was loose and similar to the bank material, raising the possibility that its standing stone was  extracted at the same time that the bank was robbed, though this remains to be determined  by OSL and radiocarbon dating. The standing stone had been pulled out from the east, away 

from the centre of the circle, and its imprint showed that the size of the stone that once  stood here was about 0.80m x 0.50m in basal cross-section. This compares closely with the  basal dimensions of Stone 46 at Stonehenge, a rhyolite of Group F, the outcrop source of  which has not yet been identified. 

Figure 9. The empty stonehole (foreground) and leaning stone (background) at Gernos-fach,  viewed from the north 

The bank was constructed of small stones and soil, the larger slabs being placed on or  towards the top of the bank. This process of construction is different to that observed for  field clearance cairns and walls where the larger stones are towards the base. A ragged line  of slabs along the bank’s inside edge may be the remnants of an inner kerb, displaced by  later activity, perhaps stone-robbing when the medieval structure was built. There was no  sign of an entrance in the north or northeast, as suggested on the surface prior to  excavation, but geophysical survey has revealed a possible access in the south, an area  heavily disturbed by later (presumably medieval) activity. 

In all three trenches there were traces of cobbling across the interior of the circle. This  reached the eastern and northern edges of the interior and covered the centre except for a  raised area which extended beyond the edges of the central trench towards the southwest  of the circle’s interior. Around this raised area, the cobbling exhibited evidence of sustained  footfall. 

Finds from the enclosing bank consisted of a flint flake, two quartz scrapers, nine quartz  flakes, six quartz cores, a large knife of igneous rock, two stone flakes, a chert spall and eight  trimmed mudstone discs of varying degrees of circularity. None of these artefacts are  necessarily diagnostic of the monument’s date which is likely to be in the range between 

Neolithic and Early Bronze Age. Radiocarbon and OSL samples were taken to see if the  monument’s different phases can be dated. 

Artefacts deposited on top of the bank included a medieval horseshoe, a sherd of medieval  Dyfed gravel-tempered ware and a sherd of Roman pottery. 

Circular, trimmed mudstone discs are also known from Waun Mawn stone circle and from  Neolithic levels at Carn Goedog bluestone quarry. Their purpose is unknown but they are  regular finds on Neolithic sites in western and northern Britain where they are usually  interpreted as ‘pot-lids’. In continental Europe they are also found in Chalcolithic and Early  Bronze Age burials where they can be identified as plates on which to place tinder for  making fire. Their purpose here in Preseli is, however, unknown – they might simply have  been no more than playthings, shaped to while away the time. Some are carefully executed  whereas others have received only the most casual working. 

Figure 10. A trimmed mudstone disc (SF132) from the eastern perimeter of Waun Mawn 

In summary, the 2021 excavations at Gernos-fach uncovered a stonehole for a removed  standing stone. The large leaning stone may be another in what may well have been an  original stone circle. Further excavation will reveal whether further stoneholes remain to be  discovered beneath the bank. The plan of this embanked circle is similar to that of Meini  Gwyr at Glandy Cross; that circle was smaller (37m in diameter) and retained its 17 standing  stones until the historical era. In comparison, the Gernos-fach stonehole raises the  possibility that this site too once sported a ring of standing stones that could have  numbered as many as 24 or so. 

Figure 11. Plan of trenches and features (black) excavated at Gernos-fach 

Acknowledgements 

We thank the landowner, Alexander Hawkesworth, and the land agent, Kathryn Perkins for  permission to excavate at Waun Mawn and Gernos-fach. Permissions were also obtained  from Natural Resources Wales and the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park. Among the staff  of PCNP, Tomos Jones and Richard Vaughan deserve a special mention for their help and  advice. We are also very grateful to Lyn and Gwyndaf Rees for on-site help and support. Simon Turner kindly arranged an evening lecture at the Bluestone Brewery.  

Supervisors were Chris Casswell, Jim Rylatt, Duncan Schlee and Jason Tyler. Specialists were  Richard Bevins, Adam Stanford, Tim Kinnaird, Clive Ruggles and Ellen Simmons (assisted by  Dave Cooper). 

Volunteers were Louise Austin, Victoria Barker, Michael Bissmire, Emma Brooks, Anne  Chambers, Ian Chambers, Stephen Cogbill, Clare Dow, John Dow, ffi Draper, Dave Durkin,  Stewart Eves, Louis Falkingham, Barney Harris, Michael Holt, Robert Hopkins, Hayley  Hughes, Rebecca Hyde, Aled Jenkins, John Jenkins, Jake Keen, Jason Lawday, Geraint Lloyd,  Stella Maddock, Michael Marshman, Lucy Mills, Ceri Owen-Jones, Richmond Pike, Ginny  Pringle, Edward Puckett, Becca Pullen, Martin Rose, Mike Standish, Julian Stanton, Anne  Teather, Julie Till, Mike Tizzard, Zoe Walsh, Jude Walter, Rob Walter, Jack Whitney, Joan  Wilks, Andy Williams, Howard Williams, Moira Williams, David Wilmshurst, Eponine Wong,  Xinyi Xie and Barbara Young. 


Saturday, 25 September 2021

Geophysical survey at the Waun Mawn Standing Stones.

In 2018, Bournemouth University’s Archaeological Consultancy, was commissioned by Mike Parker Pearson to carry out a programme of geophysical survey at the Waun Mawn Standing Stones.
In comparing the results of the two techniques, discrete responses have been identified across the survey area. Analysis of aerial photographs, however, reveals that many of these anomalies align with geological and potential archaeological features. Based on the results of the geophysical survey and the proximity of the site to several known archaeological features, the archaeological potential of the site is deemed to be medium.
 



 
The follow up report: The original Stonehenge? A dismantled stone circle in the Preseli Hills of west Wales - Mike Parker Pearson, Josh Pollard, Colin Richards, Kate Welham, Timothy Kinnaird, Dave Shaw, Ellen Simmons, Adam Stanford, Richard Bevins, Rob Ixer, Clive Ruggles, Jim Rylatt, Kevan Edinborough https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.239

Friday, 24 September 2021

Craig Rhosyfelin Reports 2011 - 2015



(Picture Tim Daw)

A quick search of https://archwilio.org.uk/ provides summaries and links to the Craig Rhosyfelin excavations of 2011 - 2015 
Craig Rhosyfelin 
Primary Reference Number (PRN) : 115069
Trust : Dyfed
Unitary authority : Pembrokeshire
Event Type : EXCAVATION
NGR : SN117362

In 2011, several archaeological works including excavation and a geophysical survey were carried out at Craig Rhosyfelin as part of the ‘Stones of Stonehenge’ Project.
The excavation demonstrates unequivocal evidence for the prehistoric quarrying of Stonehenge-sized monoliths from a source that can be matched definitively with the ‘rhyolite with fabric’ recovered from Stonehenge.
Craig Rhosyfelin has proved to be a prehistoric monolith quarry at the precise spot identified geologically as a source for Stonehenge bluestone. Further excavation will provide more evidence for the methods of quarrying and moving bluestones.
Parker Pearson, M. et al. , 2011 , The Stones of Stonehenge Project: Investigations in the Nyfer (Nevern) Valley in 2011 ©
In 2012, a excavation was carried out at Craig Rhosyfelin as part of the ‘Stones of Stonehenge’ Project.
In September 2012 an excavation of over 200sq m was carried out against the foot of the outcrop along its northwest face.
Parker Pearson, M. et al. , 2012 , The Stones of Stonehenge Project: Investigations in the Nyfer (Nevern) Valley in 2012 ©
In September 2013 most of the 2012 excavation trench was re-opened, and excavation continued.
Parker Pearson, M. et al. , 2013 , The Stones of Stonehenge Project: Investigations in the Nyfer (Nevern) Valley in 2013 ©
In 2014, Excavations were carried out at Craig Rhosyfelin as part of The Stones of Stonehenge Project. The aims of investigation in 2014 were to investigate any evidence of what methods were used to move megaliths from the quarry to their next destination. To complete excavation of the various quarry installations within the area opened in 2013. To further investigate the Mesolithic prelude to Neolithic use of the outcrop.
In conclusion, Excavations at Craig Rhosyfelin in 2014 have provided evidence of clear zonation within the megalith quarry. Perhaps the most interesting aspect is the degree of pre-quarrying landscaping, with an upper and a lower platform, the latter revetted with a drystone retaining wall. It is also noteworthy that there was a small occupation area and hearth associated with this activity although without any evidence for stakeholes or postholes that might indicate the former presence of a roofed structure.
Parker Pearson et al , 2014 , The Stones of Stonehenge Project: Interim Report 2014 ©
In 2015, Excavations were carried out at Craig Rhosyfelin as part of ‘The Stones of Stonehenge’ Project. The aims of investigation in 2015 were to extend the excavation trench at Craig Rhos-y-felin beyond the edge of the quarry and to complete excavation at Craig Rhos-y-felin of the various features within the area opened in 2014.
In conclusion, a hollow way was found leading away from the stone-built jetty that was interpreted as a ‘loading bay’ for transferring monoliths onto their wooden sledges. The narrow dimensions of the hollow way reveal that rollers cannot have been used; timbers laid in the direction of movement are the preferred interpretation.

Thursday, 19 August 2021

Clarissa Frances Miles - An overlooked early Stonehenge Photographer.

 Who was Clarissa Frances Miles - pioneer photographer of Stonehenge? Described by @MartynBarber2 as "a friend of the Antrobuses" who gives her address as Amesbury Abbey when claiming copyright for her photographs, now at the National Archive.


"born in 1860 at Malmesbury, Wiltshire, England.1 She was the daughter of Colonel Charles William Miles and Maria Susannah Hill" - http://www.thepeerage.com/p53357.htm#i533566



For more research by Martyn Barber see: https://threadreaderapp.com/convos/1362706181983207425

seems to have 46 photos - DZSWS:1986.7412/58 (search Stonehenge 1901 wiltshireheritagecollections.org.uk )

Saturday, 26 June 2021

Durrington Walls Palisade Enclosure -the 1952 excavations.

 The July-October 1954 edition of the Antiquaries Journal has an interesting write up of the 1952 excavations at Durrington Walls which I have not seen referenced before.

Stone, Piggott and Booth discovered a row, mostly a double row, of post holes that held posts when the bank was raised. They only excavated a 68 yard length so how far round the circle it went is unknown. The details are in the images below.

In 2016 excavations in the bank tested the "superhenge" theory and found that large posts had been in place before the bank was raised in the middle of the bank - for details see: https://archaeology.co.uk/articles/features/rethinking-durrington-walls-a-long-lost-monument-revealed.htm  

It would have been interesting to have discovered if the outer post row extended to the areas where the massive posts were.

A note on the journal - this edition was missing from the Wiltshire Museum library and I was lucky enough to be given it and donate it to them. It was unopened or intonso so I took the liberty of using a plastic card - better than a knife - to open the pages to take the photos for my notes. There is still a lot to learn from old reports which are too often left unread in search for the new.