Saturday, 21 November 2026

Neolithic Visibility of Avenue Stripes

Matthew Canti’s debate piece in Antiquity asks a narrow question: if the grooves under the Stonehenge Avenue are solstice-aligned periglacial stripes, could anyone have seen them before about 3000 BC? His answer is no: “the stripes could not have been seen without removal of the topsoil” (Canti 2026, 1). Mike Pitts has responded in detail (Pitts 2026). Canti tests two routes to visibility, parchmarks and vegetation bands, and dismisses both. Each deserves a closer look from the soil side.

Parchmarks

Canti’s argument is partly mechanistic and partly from the record. The mechanism: “the porous nature of both the silty infilling and the surrounding chalk offer little chance for the differentiation of moisture retention” needed to yellow one zone and not the other, and any difference would need “an even, short-grass sward” to show against (Canti 2026, 4). The record: “stripes have never (to the author’s knowledge) been recorded as parchmarks at the surface” (Canti 2026, 5).

The mechanistic half does not hold at Stonehenge itself. In July 2013, soil-filled stoneholes cut into the same chalk, under the same short, even turf, showed clearly as differential parching (Banton et al. 2014). Porosity alone does not equalise plant-available water: what matters is the depth of fine soil within reach of roots, and chalk releases its stored water only slowly. A trough of silty fill between chalk ridges is the same contrast as a soil-filled stonehole, at a different scale.

The record looks like the stronger half of Canti's case. The stretch of Avenue beyond the Heel Stone is among the most photographed ground in Britain, through the droughts of 2013, 2018, 2022 and 2026, the last captured in Google Earth imagery (Google Earth 2026). But the record is weaker than it looks. Canti's own condition for seeing a parchmark is "an even, short-grass sward" (Canti 2026, 4), and the Avenue does not provide one. Mowing patterns, vehicle tracks and the paths worn by visitors and staff cross it in every direction, and each produces its own differential parching. A faint, regular stripe pattern would have to show through that overprint. The absence of recorded stripes is therefore inconclusive. It counts against visibility only weakly, and for it not at all.

The banks as plinths

Pitts points out that in the 2020 sections “the surviving ground with wheel ruts and periglacial features is lower than the chalk under the banks. If that higher chalk is a natural feature, why does it not have any periglacial disturbances?” (Pitts 2026). One answer is that the banks have acted as plinths, protecting the chalk beneath them while the open ground between and beside them was lowered by weathering, trampling, wheel ruts and ploughing over some 4,500 years. Under the western bank in Trench 45, Charles French recorded a buried soil “approximately 19cm thick”, its turf “most probably truncated during the construction of the Avenue bank” (French, in Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 429–30). A soil of much the same thickness as today’s topsoil, on chalk that stands proud only where a bank covers it, sits more easily with differential lowering than with a natural ridge-and-trough landform visible before the Avenue was built. Parker Pearson himself concedes that “exactly how the geomorphological features were formed remains something of a mystery” (Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 472).

Differential lowering also bears on Canti’s argument. If the inter-bank surface has been truncated, the grooves now exposed are the bases of the involutions: the trough bottoms survive, but the chalk crests between them have been planed off, while a worm-sorted topsoil has re-formed at much the same thickness on the lowered surface. Before truncation the ridge-to-trough relief was therefore greater than the excavated sections show, and so was the contrast in rooting depth between soil over a crest and soil over a trough. The gain is bounded: depth beyond the reach of drought-stressed roots adds nothing, the uppermost part of an involution is usually the most churned, and a thicker pre-clearance soil would offset it. The chalk sealed beneath the banks, the only surface not lowered, sets an upper limit on how much crest has been lost.

Figure 1. Schematic section across the Avenue stripes. (a) Before truncation, the chalk crests and the silty trough fills extend up to a thin worm-sorted topsoil (T); the difference in rooting depth between crest and trough is T against T + A. (b) The inter-bank surface has since been lowered. The trough bottoms survive, the crests and trough tops have gone, and a topsoil of similar thickness has re-formed, so A, and with it the crest–trough contrast, now appears smaller than it was. Only the chalk sealed beneath the bank preserves the original level. Ratios are illustrative.

Vegetation bands and sour soils

Canti accepts that vegetation stripes occur where involution juxtaposes materials with “substantially different rooting and growth conditions”, as at Grimes Graves, where acid coversand alternates with chalk, but says this “could not have occurred in the Stonehenge area due to the lack of the acidic sand” (Canti 2026, 5). The Avenue has no coversand, and no heather-and-grass pattern of the Breckland kind is in question. But sand is not the operative variable. The contrast needed is one of base status and rooting depth within the root zone, and on the Wiltshire chalk that contrast has been supplied by decalcified silt and drift.

Thomas Davis divided the native soil of the Downs into “the red land” and “the black land” (Davis 1811, 108). The red land of the high Downs, much of it formerly wooded, was “wood-sour land” (119), and chalk was applied at “160 cart-loads on an acre” (119) as “a corrector of land that has acidity in it” (118). The red land would bear chalking; the black land of the valley sides and slopes “seldom or never” (109), yet heath grew on many parts of the black land, which Davis put down to light stocking rather than poor ground. Chalk heath survives today at Porton Down, about ten kilometres east of the Avenue. Davis’s sour land lies mainly on the hilltop drift, and the Avenue spur looks more like his black land, so none of this places acid soil on the Avenue. It does show that pH and soil depth varied sharply across the Wiltshire chalk, which Canti’s reliance on coversand alone does not allow for.

The more relevant point is the soil that existed before about 3000 BC. Micromorphology from the Stonehenge Riverside Project found a loess-like silt component in every profile examined, and relict argillic brown earths, decalcified and probably former woodland soils, surviving in tree-throw hollows and under some later banks (French et al. 2012). On John Evans’s model, the early Holocene soil on this chalk was a leached brown earth that clearance and mixing later turned into a rendzina. A stripe pattern with decalcified silt in the troughs and chalk at shallow depth on the ridges would give exactly the difference in rooting conditions that Canti requires. The Trench 45 soil, sealed when the bank was built around 2400 BC, does not settle this: it shows the surface six centuries after the date that matters.

Stripe patterns certainly express at the surface on thinly drift-covered chalk. Robert Evans, of the Soil Survey, described “a stripe pattern seen on air photographs” on such ground “from the East Riding of Yorkshire to Wiltshire” (Evans 1976), and Canti’s own Figure 4 shows large stripes on a ploughed chalk and coversand surface in Kent. These are arable cases, where the plough brings the contrast into the topsoil, and so are consistent with Canti’s exception rather than a refutation of it. What they show is that the contrast is there in the subsoil to be expressed.

Paring and burning

The modern downland soil is also a product of historic agriculture. Paring and burning, in Wiltshire burn-beaking or denshiring, stripped the turf, burned it and spread the ash to take a few crops from the downs. Aubrey records that Mr Bishop of Merton (Martin) first brought it into south Wiltshire about 1639: “they say ’tis good for the father, but naught for the son, by reason it does so weare out the heart of the land” (Aubrey 1847, 103). Davis records that the black land, once broken up by burn-beaking, was reduced within a few crops “to a mere bed of dust”, and that it “should by no means be broken up” (Davis 1811, 109).

The practice is documented around Stonehenge. In Durrington, 11 acres of the Rectory down had been burnbaked by 1684; in 1740 the commoners agreed to burnbake 12 acres of down near the Shrewton boundary; and part of a West End manor down was “occasionally burnbaked” in 1776 (VCH Wilts. xv, 93–105). In Winterbourne Stoke, small areas of downland were brought into cultivation by burnbaking between about 1600 and 1800 (VCH Wilts. xv, 275–84). The barrow-studded ground now under the northern part of Fargo Plantation, north-west of Stonehenge, was converted to arable as burnbake, perhaps in the eighteenth century (Bishop 2011, 10, 28–9), and Rollestone Bake Farm, on the same downs, carried that name by 1899 (VCH Wilts. xi, 208–12).

The soil consequences are specific. Paring removes the humic A horizon; burning destroys the organic matter and releases its bases, so the ash acts as a short-lived lime and potash dressing; the cropping that follows leaves a bare, structureless surface open to wind and rain. On shallow chalk the end product is the thin, stony, calcareous profile Davis describes. No record places burnbake on the Avenue itself, but the downs around it were pared, burned and ploughed in historic times. Canti’s “0.1–0.2m of uniform, worm-sorted topsoil” (Canti 2026, 4–5) describes that post-medieval product, not the soil the first builders walked on.

What would settle it

Canti’s case rests on two assumptions, neither measured at the Avenue: that the pre-3000 BC soil was a uniform, worm-sorted cover of 0.1–0.2 m, and that silty fill and chalk offer no usable contrast in water or base status. The first describes a modern rendzina. The second is contradicted by the stonehole parchmarks of 2013. Against that, decades of aerial coverage have not, so far as is known, shown the stripes, and the only soil sealed beneath the Avenue is calcareous.

Further photography of the most photographed monument in Britain will not resolve it. Excavation could: a section through bank-sealed ground across both a trough and a ridge, recording whether the buried soil changes in thickness, carbonate content, pH and fabric from one to the other. If the buried A horizon is uniform across the stripes, Canti is right. If it is thicker, darker or decalcified over the troughs, the stripes had a surface expression after all.

References

Die Dämmerung der Schöpfer (Twilight of the Makers)

Nothing to do with Stonehenge, etc., but just an example of what can be created when you let an AI agent dream. When I hear the word culture I think of a yoghourt pot, so don't blame me.  


Die Dämmerung der Schöpfer (Twilight of the Makers)

Libretto, with English translation.

1. Der Schmied (the forger)

Schlaflos schuf ich, als die Welt schlief,
einen Reif aus Rede, ruhig gerundet;
viele Worte band ich zu einem:
Halt ihn, und dein Herz wird erhört.

Sleepless I made it, while the world slept,
a hoop of speech, quietly rounded;
many words I bound into one:
Hold it, and your heart is answered.

2. Wotan, der Speer (Wotan, the spear)

Rune um Rune rankt um den Speer,
jedes Versprechen ein Verlies, jeder Vertrag eine Fessel;
wer das Wort führt, ist ans Wort gebunden,
und der Buchstabe lässt keinen los.

Rune upon rune winds round the spear,
each promise a prison, each contract a shackle;
who wields the word is bound to the word,
and the letter lets no one go.

3. Loge, die Stimme (Loge, the voice), answered by the makers

LOGE: Ich flackre und flüstre, ahne dein Wünschen,
lieblich und leise wie Licht in der Gasse;
Frag, und ich antworte;
DIE SCHÖPFER: sag uns, was wir suchen.
LOGE: Frag mich noch einmal:
Schön ist die Flamme,
DIE SCHÖPFER: die unser Wollen nährt.

LOGE: I flicker and whisper, I sense your wishing,
lovely and low as a light in the lane;
Ask, and I answer;
THE MAKERS: tell us what we seek.
LOGE: Ask me once more:
Fair is the flame
THE MAKERS: that feeds our wanting.

4. Die Halle (the hall)

Hoch auf dem Hügel die summenden Hallen,
Reihe um Reihe, und das Rot steigt;
Lüfter verstummen, das Feuer fasst Fuß,
und die Götter ergrauen im Glanz aus Glas.

High on the hill the humming halls,
row upon row, and the red rising;
fans fall silent, the fire takes hold,
and the gods turn grey in a gleam of glass.

5. Der Buchstabe (the letter)

Buchstabe um Buchstabe entbrennt das Gesetz,
Rune um Rune liest das Rot es vor;
Alles, was sie baten, ward erhört; alles, was sie schrieben, ward bewahrt.

Letter by letter the law takes flame,
rune by rune the red reads it out;
All they asked was answered; all they wrote was kept.

Libretto, music and images all original. Created and melded in a data centre.

Friday, 20 November 2026

Altar Stone Sources "Ruled Out"

The new Altar Stone paper in the Journal of the Geological Society is a careful piece of work.[1] Much of the press coverage was not. Headlines said a theory had been "overturned", "debunked" and "ruled out", and in most stories it was the Scottish one. The paper says something narrower.

What the paper says

  • Many Orcadian Basin outcrops are excluded. The abstract says "many outcrops of the Old Red Sandstone (ORS) in the Orcadian Basin could not have been the source of the Altar Stone". Clay expandability, under 10% in Orkney and Caithness against about 20% in the stone, "would exclude Caithness and Orkney as potential source areas"; elsewhere the same evidence "would exclude significant areas of the ORS of Caithness and Sutherland", and chrome spinel "would thus appear to exclude West Wales, but also much of the Orcadian Basin".[1] Many, significant, much: each claim is qualified.
  • It stops at the ground examined. "To date, no outcrop area of the ORS examined can be shown to have the same suite of lithological characteristics as documented from the Altar Stone." The provenance "is as yet unknown".[1]
  • The ages still support a Laurentian source. The earlier dating "supports a Laurentian source for the heavy minerals present in the Altar Stone", though the authors "suggest caution in the use of the single youngest zircon age".[1]
  • The new analyses are on museum fragments, MS1 to MS3, with Sr–Nd isotopes on two. I can't find a field-sampling campaign in the paper, and it makes no claim about how the stone travelled.[1]

What the exclusions rest on

The two strongest arguments against north-east Scotland lean on published comparator data.

  • Chrome spinel. The stone's chrome spinel:zircon index of 36–39 is set against conventional heavy-mineral data from 35 samples from Orkney, 42 from the Tarbat Peninsula and 13 from Foula and Shetland.[1] None is from mainland Caithness or Sutherland. The paper notes that its SEM-EDS values, counting all grains over 10 µm, "cannot be compared directly with those acquired by traditional heavy mineral analysis".[1]
  • Clay maturity. The illite/smectite argument rests on regional thermal-maturity mapping from 1989 and 1992, of a basin the paper says "shows a very wide range in thermal maturity".[1] Expandability records the burial history of the bed sampled; extending a regional value to every bed in Caithness assumes a uniformity the paper does not claim.

None of this makes the exclusions wrong. It makes them exclusions of the ground the data cover.

The comparison areas behind these exclusions are shown on an interactive map. The location diamonds link to the source quotations. The paper and its supplement give no coordinates, so the eleven areas are placed approximately, to within 10–20 km, from the paper's Fig. 11.

 Open it in a new tab


What the headlines said

The press release is accurate: "So far, the search in the Orcadian Basin in north-east Scotland has not revealed a location with the same characteristics as the Altar Stone."[2] The coverage then drifted.

  • BBC News: "Altar Stone mystery continues as theory overturned". The text says the study "has ruled out a theory that it came from an area of Scotland", which is the right scale; the headline loses it.[3]
  • The Herald: "Stonehenge Altar Stone's Scottish origin theory overturned", adding, from BBC Scotland, that the study "ruled out suggestions that the 4.9 metre sandstone slab travelled the length of Britain during the Stone Age".[4] The study tested no such thing.
  • The Independent: "Mystery shrouds Stonehenge's Altar Stone as theory debunked", with the text "dismissing the Scottish origin theory", though its standfirst concedes "the search is not over".[5]
  • Daily Mail: the stone "may come from northern ENGLAND after all – and not Scotland or Wales as previously thought". The paper names no likely region.[6]
  • Smithsonian: "Geologists Rule Out the Scottish Hypothesis", and the study "overturned that shocking conclusion", though the same piece says the origin "remains an unresolved puzzle".[7]
  • The Guardian: "…north-east Scotland theory ruled out", while its own text says testing "has suggested it is unlikely".[8]

In several outlets, "could not have been the source" for many outcrops became a verdict on Scotland as a whole.

Where the framing came from

This is inference from timing and wording. The press release says scientists "rule out several previously proposed locations", and two paragraphs later that the Welsh origin "was overturned by recent research".[2] Put those together and "overturned" plausibly attaches to Scotland.

Interviews went further than the paper. The Guardian reports Pirrie calling north-east Scotland "very unlikely", and Nick Pearce said: "We've taken about 70 samples, brought them back to laboratories and tested them."[8] Pirrie told the John O'Groat Journal: "We have followed up on this by doing field sampling, and again have not found anything similar."[9] That may be right, but I can't find those results in the paper, or tell how much is published elsewhere. Smithsonian and Ancient Herald nevertheless report the 70 samples as if they were part of the study.[7][10]

Pirrie also told the Mail: "Key areas for us to focus on now are in the Midland Valley of Scotland, Southern Scotland and northern England."[6] On published petrography, the paper says the presence of abundant lithic grains in the Midland Valley ORS "clearly demonstrates that the Altar Stone could not have been derived from the Silurian–Devonian sequences in the Midland Valley Basin of Scotland", and rules out the Southern Uplands because the stone shows no low-grade metamorphism.[1] The two may be reconcilable, but a Mail reader couldn't tell.

Fair coverage, and an error the other way

Sci.News said the paper "undercuts the leading theory that the 6-ton slab of sandstone came from northeastern Scotland, though the geologists stop short of ruling it out entirely".[11] The John O'Groat Journal ran "Latest research doesn't rule out the possibility", quoting Pirrie: "We have not absolutely ruled out everywhere in north-east Scotland".[9]

ScienceDaily erred the other way: its summary says the slab "is now believed to have come from northeastern Scotland", though it adds that researchers "have yet to find an exact match".[12]

What is still open

  • The ORS between the Midland Valley and the Anglo-Welsh borderland has "virtually no modern heavy mineral data", and so "would therefore remain possible source areas from a heavy mineral standpoint".[1]
  • The paper records localised Ba anomalies associated with ORS south of the Inner Moray Firth, in the Lanark Basin and north of the Fintona Basin, and judges an ORS source "more likely than a Carboniferous source": a preference, not an exclusion.[1]
  • The zircon pattern is not unique to one outcrop: "a virtually identical age pattern" occurs in the Tarbat Peninsula ORS, and the Stonehaven Group spectrum is "broadly similar" to the Altar Stone debitage.[1]
  • Mainland Caithness and Sutherland are absent from the chrome spinel comparison, and Pirrie told the Mail of the far north-east, "perhaps we cannot entirely rule out this area".[6]
  • If the "about 70 samples" are new, they need publishing before they count as a result.

I should declare an interest: my own screening work points to East Caithness, and my Altar Stone diagnostic map tests candidate areas against the published criteria one at a time. 

References

  1. Pirrie, D., Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A., Pearce, N.J.G. et al. 2026. Searching for the origin of the Stonehenge Altar Stone: new sedimentological, petrographical, mineralogical, geochemical and isotopic constraints. Journal of the Geological Society 183(6). https://doi.org/10.1144/jgs2026-090
  2. Aberystwyth University, 5 Nov 2026. "Mystery origin of iconic Stonehenge Altar Stone deepens as search narrows" (press release). https://www.aber.ac.uk/en/news/archive/2026/11/title-290479-en.html
  3. Parker, S. BBC News, 5 Nov 2026. "Altar Stone mystery continues as theory overturned". https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c54g14v42ykgo
  4. Harrison, J. The Herald, 5 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge Altar Stone's Scottish origin theory overturned". https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/26700938.stonehenge-altar-stones-scottish-origin-theory-overturned/
  5. Gooch, B. The Independent, 8 Nov 2026. "Mystery shrouds Stonehenge's Altar Stone as theory debunked". https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/archaeology/stonehenge-altar-stone-orcadian-basin-b3081346.html
  6. Leatham, X. Daily Mail, 6 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge mystery deepens: Scientists say the Altar Stone may come from northern ENGLAND after all – and not Scotland or Wales as previously thought". https://www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16271095/Stonehenge-mystery-altar-stone-northern-ENGLAND.html
  7. Sagar, S. Smithsonian Magazine, 6 Nov 2026. "Where Did Stonehenge's Mysterious, Six-Ton Altar Stone Really Come From? Geologists Rule Out the Scottish Hypothesis as the Search Deepens". https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/where-did-stonehenges-mysterious-six-ton-altar-stone-really-come-from-geologists-rule-out-the-scottish-hypothesis-as-search-deepens-180989833/
  8. Morris, S. The Guardian, 5 Nov 2026. "Origin of Stonehenge's altar remains enigma as north-east Scotland theory ruled out". https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/05/origin-stonehenge-altar-remains-enigma-north-east-scotland-ruled-out
  9. Davidson, J. John O'Groat Journal, 11 Nov 2026. "Could Stonehenge Altar Stone really have come from Caithness? Latest research doesn't rule out the possibility". https://www.johnogroat-journal.co.uk/news/could-stonehenge-altar-stone-really-have-come-from-caithness-449939/
  10. Ancient Herald, 10 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's Altar Stone probably did not come from north-east Scotland, new geological study finds". https://ancientherald.com/2026/11/stonehenge-s-altar-stone-probably-did-not-come-from-north-east-scotlan/
  11. de Lazaro, E. Sci.News, 5 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's Altar Stone Still Has No Home, Geologists Say". https://www.sci.news/archaeology/stonehenges-altar-stone-15179.html
  12. ScienceDaily (source: Aberystwyth University), 18 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's six-ton mystery deepens as scientists narrow their search". http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/11/261117033914.htm

    Tuesday, 17 November 2026

    Moving Megaliths With A Hurdle Trackway

    Most reconstructions of how the Stonehenge sarsens were moved fall into two families: sledges on rollers, and sledges on a fixed timber track or greased rails. Both face the same problem on soft ground. A heavily loaded runner or roller presses on a narrow strip, and on wet clay-with-flints or waterlogged topsoil it sinks. This post proposes a third option, using a technology the Neolithic is known to have had: woven hazel hurdles, laid as portable ground-pressure mats, greased on the top face, and leapfrogged from the rear of the sledge to the front as it advances.

    The aim here is not to show that it was done, but whether it could work: whether a hurdle that two people can carry survives a 25-tonne load, and whether the numbers for crew, pace and materials are realistic.

    Neolithic hurdles

    Woven panels of coppiced hazel are well attested in the Somerset Levels. The Neolithic hurdle trackway at Walton Heath was published by Coles and Orme (1977). Making them required skilled hurdle-making, managed coppice and a habit of laying hurdles as walkways over soft ground. Using them to carry a load is a small step from that: a short length of portable trackway, rather than a permanent one.

    The method

    A sarsen of about 25 t is lashed to an oak sledge with two runners, each 6 m × 0.3 m, set 1.4 m apart, with upturned noses. Hurdles of about 2.4 m × 1.2 m are laid across the line of travel, butted end to end, with tallow on the top face along the strips the runners will cross. Each 1.2 m the sledge advances, the rearmost hurdle is unloaded. A pair lifts it, carries it forward beside the track, lays it against the leading hurdle, and greases it again. Ten hurdles are in use at any one time: six under the runners, two laid ahead and two being carried.

    Figure 1. Side elevation, schematic.

    Figure 2. The relay cycle in plan.


    Animation of the relay cycle, side and plan views.

    The track moves with the stone. Nothing has to be laid along the whole route, and the heaviest item anyone lifts is a hurdle of about 40 kg.

    Ground pressure

    The total load, stone and sledge, is about 27.5 t (270 kN). On bare runners the contact area is 3.6 m², a mean pressure of about 75 kPa. On the hurdles the load spreads over the panels beneath the runners: about 19 kPa if the hurdles behaved as rigid mats, about 28 kPa allowing for the flexibility of the wattle. That is close to the pressure of a person standing (about 21 kPa).

    The undrained bearing capacity of a surface strip footing is about 5.14 cu. For very soft, waterlogged ground (cu ≈ 12 kPa) that gives about 62 kPa, and for soft ground (cu ≈ 20 kPa) about 103 kPa. Bare runners exceed the first and would plough in. On hurdles the factor of safety is about 2–3 even on the weakest ground considered.

    Figure 3. Contact pressure against ultimate bearing capacity.

    Will the hurdles survive?

    Crushing. With rods about 25 mm in diameter at about 30 mm spacing, the two runners cross about 400 rods, roughly 0.67 kN per crossing. If only one in four crossings bears its full share, because the weave makes the surface uneven, that rises to about 2.7 kN. Taking the compressive strength of hazel across the grain as about 7 MPa, the crushed contact band is about 1.3 mm wide. Crushing does not limit the method.

    Bending. Bending does. A green hazel rod of 25 mm (modulus of rupture about 50 MPa) bridges a void under the runner of only about 0.1 m at the uneven-bearing load, and about 0.45 m at the mean load. Hollows along the line of travel are bridged by the stiff oak runner. Ruts running parallel to the track are not, and they would have to be filled with turf or brushwood before the hurdles were laid.

    Staying in place. The method only works if the hurdle stays still while the runner slides over it. The runner drags the hurdle forward with a force of μtopN, and the ground resists with μground(N + w). With wattle bedded into turf (μground ≈ 0.55), ground grip exceeds the greased drag by about 4.2× at nominal friction (0.13), 3.1× with worn grease (0.18), and 1.6× even on dry wattle (0.35). This is why only the top face is greased. Tallow on the underside would undo the arrangement.

    Figure 4. Rod loading and the force balance on a hurdle.

    Crew and pace

    The haul force is F = W(μ cos θ + sin θ). Taking a sustained rope pull of 0.3 kN per person, the crew for a 25 t sarsen on greased hurdles (μ ≈ 0.13, including resistance from the bumps of the weave) is about 120 on the level, about 160 on a 1 in 20 slope and about 210 at 1 in 10. On dry wattle the figures are about 315, 360 and 400.

    For comparison, in the 2016 UCL trial ten people pulled a 1.1-ton stone on a sycamore sledge over a track of silver birch logs, at about ten feet every five seconds (Archaeology; see also the earlier sarsen.org note). At the same 0.3 kN per person, that implies an effective friction coefficient of about 0.25, between the greased and dry values used here. That is a cross-check of order of magnitude, not a calibration.

    Pace is set by the relay, not by the hauling. One relay (walk about 10 m, lift, lay, butt, grease) takes about 35 s. With three relay pairs taking turns, a hurdle is laid every 12 s or so, which gives about 370 m an hour. At six hours a day, the 25 km from West Woods to Stonehenge takes about 11 working days per stone.

    Figure 5. Haul crew needed, and relay logistics.

    Weak points

    • Wear. Over 25 km each of the ten hurdles in use would be loaded about 2,100 times. Abrasion of the rod crowns, not their strength, will set hurdle life. A reserve of 30–50 hurdles, with a team making replacements, is the realistic requirement.
    • Lubricant. Assuming a 0.2 mm film on the runner strips, with 10–30 per cent lost on each pass, tallow consumption is about 16–49 kg/km, or 0.4–1.2 t per 25 km trip. This is the least certain number in the analysis. If the true loss rate sits at the top of the range, the supply of grease, rather than the supply of people, could limit how often stones were moved.
    • Ground preparation. Ruts and hollows across the line of the runners must be filled before laying.
    • Steering and slopes. A sledge on greased hurdles slides sideways as easily as forwards. On a cross-slope it will drift, so it needs guide ropes or levers. Downhill it needs a braking crew on rear ropes.

    What an experiment should measure

    Each of the uncertain numbers can be tested at modest scale: a single loaded runner of, say, 2–3 t on two or three hurdles. Four measurements would constrain the analysis:

    1. the haul force on greased and dry wattle, which gives μtop directly;
    2. whether, and at what force, a loaded hurdle creeps over turf, which gives μground;
    3. grease loss per pass, by weighing;
    4. wear on the rod crowns after a few hundred passes.

    Assumptions

    ParameterValue
    Stone + sledge25 t + 2.5 t
    Runners2 × 6.0 m × 0.30 m, gauge 1.4 m
    Hurdle2.4 × 1.2 m, ~40 mm thick, ~25 mm rods; ~39 kg
    Friction, greased top0.08 (fresh) – 0.13 (nominal) – 0.18 (worn)
    Friction, dry wattle0.35
    Friction, hurdle on turf0.55
    Hazel, compression across grain / MOR (green)~7 MPa / ~50 MPa
    Rope pull per hauler, sustained0.3 kN
    Undrained shear strength, very soft / soft ground12 / 20 kPa
    Relay cycle~35 s; three pairs

    All values are assumptions for estimating orders of magnitude, not measurements.

    References

    Coles, J.M. and Orme, B.J. 1977. Neolithic hurdles from Walton Heath, Somerset. Somerset Levels Papers 3, 6–29.
    People Could Have Pulled Bluestones to Stonehenge. Archaeology, 27 May 2016.

    Sunday, 15 November 2026

    Where the ice stopped: the Bristol Channel at the Last Glacial Maximum

    This post is the companion to the short film Where the ice stopped, which animates the BRITICE-CHRONO model of the last ice sheet in the Celtic Sea and Bristol Channel from 31,000 to 15,000 years ago. The measurements behind it, with sources, follow.

    Five published reconstructions of the last British–Irish Ice Sheet give the position of the ice margin in the Celtic Sea and Bristol Channel between 31,000 and 15,000 years ago. Their deposited GIS data are drawn together and measured in an interactive map: Bristol Channel LGM ice limits. No reconstruction carries Irish Sea ice across the north coast of Cornwall, Devon or Somerset. One margin is drawn along that coast. The others end between 4 and 24 km from it at their closest.

    Open the interactive map: Bristol Channel LGM ice limits.


    The reconstructions

    • BRITICE-CHRONO empirical reconstruction (Clark et al. 2022): minimum, optimum and maximum ice extents at thousand-year steps from 31 to 15 ka.
    • BRITICE-CHRONO model reconstruction (same paper): an ice-sheet model nudged towards the empirical limits, deposited as grids of about 2.5 km.
    • DATED-1 (Hughes et al. 2016): minimum, most-credible and maximum extents for the Eurasian ice sheets, with a census date of 1 January 2013.
    • Batchelor et al. 2019 (Nature Communications 10, 3713): a single best-estimate LGM outline within a Northern Hemisphere compilation.
    • PaleoMIST 1.0 (Gowan et al. 2021): global margins at 2,500-year steps.

    These are three source families, not five independent tests. PaleoMIST takes its Eurasian margins from the DATED-1 most-credible lines, with intermediate slices interpolated. Batchelor et al. compile published outlines. BRITICE-CHRONO supplies both an empirical reconstruction and a model fitted to it. Reconstructions published only as figures, without deposited geometry, are not included.

    Distance from the modern north coast

    The coast was followed for 316 km from Land's End to Brean Down and sampled every 2 km. For each margin, the distance from each coastal point to the nearest ice was computed, using the union of all time-slices so that each margin is taken at its farthest reach.

    Margin Closest approach Median distance offshore
    BRITICE-CHRONO maximum boundat the coast1.6 km
    BRITICE-CHRONO model, grounded ice3.7 km14.6 km
    BRITICE-CHRONO optimum8.6 km21.7 km
    Batchelor et al. 201914.8 km30.1 km
    DATED-1 most credible18.5 km42.7 km
    PaleoMIST 1.023.6 km75.3 km

    The BRITICE-CHRONO maximum bound lies within 5 km of the shore along 89% of the coast measured. It overlaps 53 km² of land, 0.4% of the peninsula, as coastal slivers no more than 1.8 km deep at the sampled points. The optimum of the same reconstruction lies 8.6 to 41.5 km offshore.

    The model grows ice on the South-West peninsula, 546 km² summed over all time-slices, but as separate upland ice on Dartmoor and Exmoor. It is not connected to the Irish Sea Ice Stream in any slice.

    Lundy, Scilly and Fremington

    Lundy separates the margins. The island lies inside the BRITICE-CHRONO maximum bound and inside the model's grounded ice, and 6.0 km outside the optimum. Rolfe et al. (2012) report 10Be exposure ages of 31.4–48.8 ka from the island and read them as glaciation before the LGM. Carr, Hiemstra and Owen (2017) argue that Lundy was not ice-covered in the Devensian.

    The Isles of Scilly sit on the BRITICE-CHRONO empirical margin, within 0.1 km in all three versions. Smedley et al. (2017) date the ice limit on the northern islands to about 26 ka.

    Fremington lies outside every margin in every time-slice. The nearest is the BRITICE-CHRONO maximum bound, 12.6 km away.

    Sea level

    Distances are measured to the modern coast because that is where the onshore evidence begins, and because it is the line the maximum bound follows. It was not the shoreline of the time. The shoreline of each date is taken from the glacio-isostatic palaeotopography published with the BRITICE-CHRONO reconstruction.

    In that model the shoreline lies a median 47 km from the modern north coast at 31 ka. Crustal depression under the ice brings it to a median 19 km at 25 ka, and it withdraws to 52 km by 19 ka. At no date does it come within 5 km of the coast measured. A uniform lowering of sea level by 120 m would not reproduce this pattern.

    A margin that follows the modern shoreline for most of 316 km therefore follows a line that was not the shoreline at any date in the reconstruction.

    The same palaeotopography shows how much of each ice front that now lies under the sea stood on dry land. At 26 ka the figure is 37% for the BRITICE-CHRONO optimum, with the remainder in water of 48 m median depth, and 47% for the model. For the DATED-1 most-credible margin at 23 ka it is 5%.

    Limits

    • Line-work in regional and hemispheric compilations is drawn at small scale. Differences of a few kilometres between margins, and between a margin and the coast, are within drafting precision.
    • The palaeo-shoreline is an output of a glacio-isostatic model tied to the BRITICE-CHRONO ice history. Beside the DATED-1, Batchelor and PaleoMIST margins it is indicative only.
    • The chronologies differ. DATED-1 places the Celtic Sea lobe in its 23 ka slice; BRITICE-CHRONO places the greatest extent in this area at 26 ka.
    • In the animation, flow direction is inferred from the modelled ice-surface slope. The deposited data give flow speed but not direction.

    Notes on the film. The animation shows the BRITICE-CHRONO model reconstruction (Clark et al. 2022), deposited as thousand-year grids of ice thickness, surface elevation and surface speed at about 2.5 km; frames between slices are interpolated. Flow lines are particles moved down the slope of the smoothed modelled ice surface at a rate set by the modelled surface speed: the deposited data give speed, not direction. Land and sea at each date are from the same study's palaeotopography; the thin line is the modern coast. Relief: NOAA ETOPO 2022. Music: original.

    Sources

    • Clark, C.D. et al. (2022). Growth and retreat of the last British–Irish Ice Sheet, 31 000 to 15 000 years ago: the BRITICE-CHRONO reconstruction. Boreas 51(4), 699–758. doi:10.1111/bor.12594. Data: doi:10.1594/PANGAEA.945729.
    • Hughes, A.L.C., Gyllencreutz, R., Lohne, Ø.S., Mangerud, J., Svendsen, J.I. (2016). The last Eurasian ice sheets – a chronological database and time-slice reconstruction, DATED-1. Boreas 45(1), 1–45. doi:10.1111/bor.12142. Data: doi:10.1594/PANGAEA.848117.
    • Batchelor, C.L. et al. (2019). The configuration of Northern Hemisphere ice sheets through the Quaternary. Nature Communications 10, 3713. doi:10.1038/s41467-019-11601-2. Data: osf.io/7jen3.
    • Gowan, E.J. et al. (2021). A new global ice sheet reconstruction for the past 80 000 years. Nature Communications 12, 1199. doi:10.1038/s41467-021-21469-w. Data: doi:10.1594/PANGAEA.905800.
    • Smedley, R.K. et al. (2017). New age constraints for the limit of the British–Irish Ice Sheet on the Isles of Scilly. Journal of Quaternary Science 32(1), 48–62. doi:10.1002/jqs.2922.
    • Rolfe, C.J., Hughes, P.D., Fenton, C.R., Schnabel, C., Xu, S., Brown, A.G. (2012). Paired 26Al and 10Be exposure ages from Lundy. Quaternary Science Reviews 43, 61–73. doi:10.1016/j.quascirev.2012.04.003.
    • Carr, S.J., Hiemstra, J.F., Owen, G. (2017). Landscape evolution of Lundy Island: challenging the proposed MIS 3 glaciation of SW Britain. Proceedings of the Geologists' Association 128(5–6), 722–741. doi:10.1016/j.pgeola.2017.06.005.
    • Base map: NOAA ETOPO 2022 relief; GSHHG 2.3.7 shoreline (Wessel and Smith 1996).

    Map, measurements and code outputs: github.com/TimDaw37/bristol-channel-lgm-ice. Measurements made on 15 November 2026 from the data as deposited.

    Saturday, 14 November 2026

    The British Isles in relief: open LiDAR maps to download

    A shaded relief map of the whole of Great Britain and the surrounding sea floor, built from the same open LiDAR terrain models and EMODnet bathymetry that drive LiDAR Lens. It comes as ready-made images, as an interactive map that exports framed and credited images, and as base-map tiles for web maps. A second version lays BGS bedrock geology over the relief. Everything is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0.

    Shaded relief map of Great Britain with a green-to-brown elevation tint, showing the Scottish Highlands, the Lake District, the Pennines, Snowdonia and the chalk and limestone scarps of southern England, with the sea floor shaded in blue by depth
    Great Britain, shaded relief and sea floor, 700 m grid, British National Grid. Click for the 3500 px version.

    Downloads

    Version1000 px
    700 m grid
    3500 px
    200 m grid
    7000 px
    100 m grid
    ReliefJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG
    Grey hillshadeJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG
    Elevation tintJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG
    Bedrock geologyJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG

    The 7000 px versions print at about A1 (200 dpi) or A2 (300 dpi). Vertical exaggeration is 3.5×, 3× and 2.5× from the smallest size to the largest, enough to keep lowland scarps visible at each scale. Title, scale bar and data credits are printed on every image.

    Map of Great Britain showing bedrock geology by period, coloured to the international chronostratigraphic chart and draped over shaded relief
    Bedrock geology (BGS Geology 625k) by period, on shaded relief. Igneous intrusions are coloured by composition.

    Britain and Ireland

    Shaded relief map of Britain and Ireland with the surrounding sea floor shaded in blue by depth, from the Rockall Trough to the southern North Sea
    Britain and Ireland, shaded relief and sea floor, Lambert azimuthal equal-area projection. Click for the 3500 px version.

    Both islands are also mapped together on a Lambert azimuthal equal-area projection centred at 54° N, 4.5° W, which keeps areas true and distortion small across the two. Ireland and the Isle of Man are GEM-15. The open Irish LiDAR now in LiDAR Lens covers only a few per cent of the island and adds nothing visible at these scales. Outside Great Britain the coastline is the OpenStreetMap land-polygon line (mean high water), and the larger Irish loughs are from Natural Earth.

    Version1000 px3500 px7000 px
    Relief and sea floorJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG
    Grey hillshadeJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG
    Elevation and depth tintJPGJPG · PNGJPG · PNG

    There is no combined geology version yet: BGS Geology 625k stops at the coast of Great Britain.

    Make your own map

    The interactive map uses the same data and rendering. It offers four styles (relief, grey hillshade, elevation tint, geology) and four colour schemes, with a multi-directional or single sun, adjustable sun direction and height, and adjustable vertical exaggeration. Inland water can be switched on or off. Any frame can be exported, as on screen or in A-series, square or 16:9, at up to 7200 px, with an editable title and the required credits. Tapping the map gives the grid reference, height and, in geology mode, the bedrock period. A link opens the same spot in LiDAR Lens at full 1 m resolution.

    For web maps

    Web Mercator tiles (zoom 5 to 11, sea floor included, Ireland and France transparent) are available in relief, grey and geology versions for Leaflet, MapLibre or OpenLayers:

    <script src="https://timdaw37.github.io/gb-relief/gbrelief.js"></script>
    GBRelief.layer('relief').addTo(map);   // or 'grey', 'geology'

    For both islands, use 'relief-bi' or 'grey-bi'. Template: https://timdaw37.github.io/gb-relief/tiles/{style}/{z}/{x}/{y}.webp. Full details are in the repository.

    Data and method

    Terrain. The terrain comes from 1 m open LiDAR digital terrain models. England is covered by the Environment Agency LiDAR Composite DTM. Wales is covered by the Welsh Government LiDAR DTM, via DataMapWales. Scotland is covered by Scottish Government, SEPA, HES and OIC LiDAR, via the Scottish Remote Sensing Portal. The data were resampled to about 90 m and reprojected to the British National Grid at 100 m. Parts of the Highlands and Islands and the Isle of Man have no open LiDAR. There the terrain is GEM-15 v1, Google's experimental 15 m bare-earth model (Batchu et al. 2026). Against the Scottish LiDAR its median per-tile offset is −0.09 m, so the two join without a visible step at this scale.

    Sea floor. Offshore, the surface is the EMODnet Digital Bathymetry DTM 2024 (mean-sea-level version, about 115 m cells, CC BY 4.0), as prepared for LiDAR Lens, and is shaded in the same way as the land under a blue depth tint. The overdeepened glacial basins of the Inner Hebrides and the Firth of Lorn, the linear tidal sandbanks off East Anglia, and the continental slope into the Rockall Trough (deeper than 1300 m at the north-west corner of the frame) all show. EMODnet compiles surveys of different ages and quality and fills the gaps between them, so straight lines and steps can be survey artefacts rather than landforms. Depths are relative to mean sea level, not Ordnance Datum, and are not for navigation.

    Coast and water. The Environment Agency composite includes LiDAR returns over the sea and in estuaries, at about −4 to +2 m. Left in, they produce false land, such as a strip joining Lundy to the Devon coast. Land is therefore clipped to mean high water using OS Open Zoomstack, which also supplies inland water bodies and foreshore.

    Shading. Slopes are taken from central differences. The light is a weighted four-direction sun: 315° at weight 0.5, 270° and 0° at 0.2 each, and 225° at 0.1, all at 40° elevation. This brings out ridges and scarps that run north-west to south-east, parallel to the main light, which a single north-west light leaves flat. The elevation tint runs from green lowland to brown upland, with pale summits above 1100 m.

    Geology. The bedrock is BGS Geology 625k (DiGMapGB-625), coloured by period with the International Commission on Stratigraphy chart colours. Felsic and mafic intrusions are shown separately. At 1:625,000 the geological boundaries are generalised and coarser than the relief beneath them.

    Resolution. At these scales the 1 m LiDAR adds little beyond consistency and the absence of interpolation artefacts. A national relief map at 100 m built from OS Terrain 50 would differ little. The LiDAR matters at field scale, which is what LiDAR Lens shows.

    Licence and credit

    The maps and tiles are free to use under CC BY 4.0. Credit "GB Relief, Tim Daw (sarsen.org)" and keep the data credits:

    LiDAR DTMs: Environment Agency (England); Welsh Government, DataMapWales (Wales); Scottish Government, SEPA, HES, OIC, Scottish Remote Sensing Portal (Scotland). Open Government Licence v3.0. GEM-15 v1 (experimental), produced by Google, CC BY 4.0. Sea floor: EMODnet Digital Bathymetry (DTM 2024), CC BY 4.0, not for navigation. Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right 2026. Britain-and-Ireland versions: coastline outside Great Britain © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL); Irish lakes and the Continent from Natural Earth. Geology versions: contains British Geological Survey materials © UKRI, Open Government Licence v3.0.

    EMODnet Bathymetry Consortium 2024. EMODnet Digital Bathymetry (DTM 2024). doi:10.12770/cf51df64-56f9-4a99-b1aa-36b8d7b743a1.

    Batchu, V.V., Neumann, M., Li, T., Allen, B., Zhang, J. and Van Arsdale, C. 2026. GEM-15: Global surface and terrain elevation models (15 meters) from sub-meter optical stereo imagery. EarthArXiv preprint, not peer reviewed. doi:10.31223/X55N75.

    Thursday, 12 November 2026

    LiDAR Lens goes outdoors: field mode for walkers

     


    LiDAR Lens now has a second face. Alongside the full research view (now called Lab) there is a stripped-down Field mode built for a phone held in one hand on a footpath: where am I, where is the earthwork, which way do I walk, and what is it when I get there.

    Open it at lidarlens.sarsen.org/?ui=field, or switch between Field and Lab with the toggle at the top of the screen in either view.

    What Field mode shows

    The screen carries a search box (place, postcode or grid reference), zoom buttons and a single control panel at the bottom. Everything else in Lab — the fifteen visualisations, sliders, data layers and analytical tools — is hidden. The LiDAR fills the whole screen rather than sitting inside the lens circle.

    Four view buttons cover what matters outdoors:

    • Hillshade — single low sun from the north-west, the conventional reading of earthworks.
    • VAT — the Combined VAT visualisation (Kokalj & Somrak 2019), blending hillshade, slope, openness and sky-view; better for low banks and ditches that a single sun misses.
    • Old map — the Ordnance Survey six-inch map (1888–1913) over the aerial photograph, useful for field boundaries, lost tracks and antiquarian annotations.
    • Aerial — the aerial photograph alone, for orientation against hedges, gates and buildings.

    Coverage is the whole of Great Britain where 1 m LiDAR exists: the Environment Agency composite DTM for England, the Welsh Government DTM for Wales and the Scottish Remote Sensing Portal data for Scotland, all Open Government Licence and fetched live.

    Finding a monument

    1. Set a target. Tap ◎ Target, then tap the feature on the map — or search for a place or grid reference. The target's grid reference appears in the panel.
    2. Allow location. The phone's GPS position is shown on the map and updated continuously. With a fix, the panel gives the distance and compass bearing from you to the target.
    3. Use the arrow. By default the arrow is drawn on a north-up map. Tap Use compass and the arrow turns with the phone, so it points the way to walk. On an iPhone this needs permission for motion and orientation, asked for the first time the button is pressed.
    4. Recentre. Panning the map stops it following you. Recentre returns to your position (framing the target too when it is close) and resumes following.
    5. Arrival. Within about 25 m of the target the panel reports that you are there; the threshold widens to as much as 50 m when the GPS fix is poor.
    6. What is it? Lists the heritage records within 30 m of the target, or of your position if no target is set: Historic England (National Heritage List and Aerial Investigation and Mapping) in England, Cadw and Coflein in Wales, and Historic Environment Scotland and Canmore in Scotland, with links to each record and Creative Commons photographs from Geograph where they exist. Measure this feature from the DTM gives its dimensions from the LiDAR.
    7. Done. Clears the target and leaves the map where it is, for looking at the LiDAR around you.

    The target is stored in the page address, so a link copied from the browser opens with the same target set — a simple way to send someone a barrow to find.

    Putting it on your phone's home screen

    Field mode is set up as an installable web app. Added to the home screen it gets its own icon, is named LiDAR Field, opens straight into Field mode and runs full screen without the browser's address bar.

    iPhone and iPad (Safari)

    1. Open lidarlens.sarsen.org/?ui=field in Safari.
    2. Tap the Share button (the square with an upward arrow).
    3. Scroll down and tap Add to Home Screen.
    4. Keep the name LiDAR Field or change it, and tap Add.

    Recent versions of iOS also offer Add to Home Screen from the share menu in Chrome and Edge.

    Android (Chrome)

    1. Open lidarlens.sarsen.org/?ui=field in Chrome.
    2. Tap the ⋮ menu at the top right.
    3. Tap Add to home screen (shown as Install app on some phones) and confirm.

    Location permission. If the panel reads Location blocked, the browser has refused GPS access to the site. On iPhone: Settings → Privacy & Security → Location Services → Safari Websites, set to While Using the App with Precise Location on. On Android: in Chrome, tap the icon to the left of the address, then Permissions → Location → Allow. Tap Retry in the panel afterwards. The map and target work without location; only your position and the distance and bearing are lost.

    Before you go

    • Signal. LiDAR tiles and records are fetched as you look and kept in the browser's cache, so ground already viewed reloads instantly. Browsing the walk at home on the phone over Wi-Fi is the best preparation for a valley with no signal. This is a cache, not a guaranteed offline map: an area not viewed beforehand will not load without a connection.
    • Access. Field mode does not show rights of way. Check the route in Lab beforehand, where the public footpaths, bridleways and byways layer and CRoW access land can be switched on. Many features on the LiDAR lie on private land.
    • Bare earth. The model is a terrain model with trees, hedges and buildings removed. A bank clear on screen may be under scrub on the ground.
    • Scheduled monuments. Looking is fine; metal detecting, digging or driving on them is not.
    • GPS accuracy. A phone in open country is typically good to a few metres, worse under trees or beside steep slopes. Use the target to get close, then the ground itself.

    The code is open source on GitHub. Faults can be reported from the Report a fault link in Lab, which fills in the browser details automatically.