Friday, 20 November 2026

Altar Stone Sources "Ruled Out"

The new Altar Stone paper in the Journal of the Geological Society is a careful piece of work.[1] Much of the press coverage was not. Headlines said a theory had been "overturned", "debunked" and "ruled out", and in most stories it was the Scottish one. The paper says something narrower.

What the paper says

  • Many Orcadian Basin outcrops are excluded. The abstract says "many outcrops of the Old Red Sandstone (ORS) in the Orcadian Basin could not have been the source of the Altar Stone". Clay expandability, under 10% in Orkney and Caithness against about 20% in the stone, "would exclude Caithness and Orkney as potential source areas"; elsewhere the same evidence "would exclude significant areas of the ORS of Caithness and Sutherland", and chrome spinel "would thus appear to exclude West Wales, but also much of the Orcadian Basin".[1] Many, significant, much: each claim is qualified.
  • It stops at the ground examined. "To date, no outcrop area of the ORS examined can be shown to have the same suite of lithological characteristics as documented from the Altar Stone." The provenance "is as yet unknown".[1]
  • The ages still support a Laurentian source. The earlier dating "supports a Laurentian source for the heavy minerals present in the Altar Stone", though the authors "suggest caution in the use of the single youngest zircon age".[1]
  • The new analyses are on museum fragments, MS1 to MS3, with Sr–Nd isotopes on two. I can't find a field-sampling campaign in the paper, and it makes no claim about how the stone travelled.[1]

What the exclusions rest on

The two strongest arguments against north-east Scotland lean on published comparator data.

  • Chrome spinel. The stone's chrome spinel:zircon index of 36–39 is set against conventional heavy-mineral data from 35 samples from Orkney, 42 from the Tarbat Peninsula and 13 from Foula and Shetland.[1] None is from mainland Caithness or Sutherland. The paper notes that its SEM-EDS values, counting all grains over 10 µm, "cannot be compared directly with those acquired by traditional heavy mineral analysis".[1]
  • Clay maturity. The illite/smectite argument rests on regional thermal-maturity mapping from 1989 and 1992, of a basin the paper says "shows a very wide range in thermal maturity".[1] Expandability records the burial history of the bed sampled; extending a regional value to every bed in Caithness assumes a uniformity the paper does not claim.

None of this makes the exclusions wrong. It makes them exclusions of the ground the data cover.

The comparison areas behind these exclusions are shown on an interactive map. The location diamonds link to the source quotations. The paper and its supplement give no coordinates, so the eleven areas are placed approximately, to within 10–20 km, from the paper's Fig. 11.

 Open it in a new tab


What the headlines said

The press release is accurate: "So far, the search in the Orcadian Basin in north-east Scotland has not revealed a location with the same characteristics as the Altar Stone."[2] The coverage then drifted.

  • BBC News: "Altar Stone mystery continues as theory overturned". The text says the study "has ruled out a theory that it came from an area of Scotland", which is the right scale; the headline loses it.[3]
  • The Herald: "Stonehenge Altar Stone's Scottish origin theory overturned", adding, from BBC Scotland, that the study "ruled out suggestions that the 4.9 metre sandstone slab travelled the length of Britain during the Stone Age".[4] The study tested no such thing.
  • The Independent: "Mystery shrouds Stonehenge's Altar Stone as theory debunked", with the text "dismissing the Scottish origin theory", though its standfirst concedes "the search is not over".[5]
  • Daily Mail: the stone "may come from northern ENGLAND after all – and not Scotland or Wales as previously thought". The paper names no likely region.[6]
  • Smithsonian: "Geologists Rule Out the Scottish Hypothesis", and the study "overturned that shocking conclusion", though the same piece says the origin "remains an unresolved puzzle".[7]
  • The Guardian: "…north-east Scotland theory ruled out", while its own text says testing "has suggested it is unlikely".[8]

In several outlets, "could not have been the source" for many outcrops became a verdict on Scotland as a whole.

Where the framing came from

This is inference from timing and wording. The press release says scientists "rule out several previously proposed locations", and two paragraphs later that the Welsh origin "was overturned by recent research".[2] Put those together and "overturned" plausibly attaches to Scotland.

Interviews went further than the paper. The Guardian reports Pirrie calling north-east Scotland "very unlikely", and Nick Pearce said: "We've taken about 70 samples, brought them back to laboratories and tested them."[8] Pirrie told the John O'Groat Journal: "We have followed up on this by doing field sampling, and again have not found anything similar."[9] That may be right, but I can't find those results in the paper, or tell how much is published elsewhere. Smithsonian and Ancient Herald nevertheless report the 70 samples as if they were part of the study.[7][10]

Pirrie also told the Mail: "Key areas for us to focus on now are in the Midland Valley of Scotland, Southern Scotland and northern England."[6] On published petrography, the paper says the presence of abundant lithic grains in the Midland Valley ORS "clearly demonstrates that the Altar Stone could not have been derived from the Silurian–Devonian sequences in the Midland Valley Basin of Scotland", and rules out the Southern Uplands because the stone shows no low-grade metamorphism.[1] The two may be reconcilable, but a Mail reader couldn't tell.

Fair coverage, and an error the other way

Sci.News said the paper "undercuts the leading theory that the 6-ton slab of sandstone came from northeastern Scotland, though the geologists stop short of ruling it out entirely".[11] The John O'Groat Journal ran "Latest research doesn't rule out the possibility", quoting Pirrie: "We have not absolutely ruled out everywhere in north-east Scotland".[9]

ScienceDaily erred the other way: its summary says the slab "is now believed to have come from northeastern Scotland", though it adds that researchers "have yet to find an exact match".[12]

What is still open

  • The ORS between the Midland Valley and the Anglo-Welsh borderland has "virtually no modern heavy mineral data", and so "would therefore remain possible source areas from a heavy mineral standpoint".[1]
  • The paper records localised Ba anomalies associated with ORS south of the Inner Moray Firth, in the Lanark Basin and north of the Fintona Basin, and judges an ORS source "more likely than a Carboniferous source": a preference, not an exclusion.[1]
  • The zircon pattern is not unique to one outcrop: "a virtually identical age pattern" occurs in the Tarbat Peninsula ORS, and the Stonehaven Group spectrum is "broadly similar" to the Altar Stone debitage.[1]
  • Mainland Caithness and Sutherland are absent from the chrome spinel comparison, and Pirrie told the Mail of the far north-east, "perhaps we cannot entirely rule out this area".[6]
  • If the "about 70 samples" are new, they need publishing before they count as a result.

I should declare an interest: my own screening work points to East Caithness, and my Altar Stone diagnostic map tests candidate areas against the published criteria one at a time. 

References

  1. Pirrie, D., Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A., Pearce, N.J.G. et al. 2026. Searching for the origin of the Stonehenge Altar Stone: new sedimentological, petrographical, mineralogical, geochemical and isotopic constraints. Journal of the Geological Society 183(6). https://doi.org/10.1144/jgs2026-090
  2. Aberystwyth University, 5 Nov 2026. "Mystery origin of iconic Stonehenge Altar Stone deepens as search narrows" (press release). https://www.aber.ac.uk/en/news/archive/2026/11/title-290479-en.html
  3. Parker, S. BBC News, 5 Nov 2026. "Altar Stone mystery continues as theory overturned". https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c54g14v42ykgo
  4. Harrison, J. The Herald, 5 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge Altar Stone's Scottish origin theory overturned". https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/26700938.stonehenge-altar-stones-scottish-origin-theory-overturned/
  5. Gooch, B. The Independent, 8 Nov 2026. "Mystery shrouds Stonehenge's Altar Stone as theory debunked". https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/archaeology/stonehenge-altar-stone-orcadian-basin-b3081346.html
  6. Leatham, X. Daily Mail, 6 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge mystery deepens: Scientists say the Altar Stone may come from northern ENGLAND after all – and not Scotland or Wales as previously thought". https://www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16271095/Stonehenge-mystery-altar-stone-northern-ENGLAND.html
  7. Sagar, S. Smithsonian Magazine, 6 Nov 2026. "Where Did Stonehenge's Mysterious, Six-Ton Altar Stone Really Come From? Geologists Rule Out the Scottish Hypothesis as the Search Deepens". https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/where-did-stonehenges-mysterious-six-ton-altar-stone-really-come-from-geologists-rule-out-the-scottish-hypothesis-as-search-deepens-180989833/
  8. Morris, S. The Guardian, 5 Nov 2026. "Origin of Stonehenge's altar remains enigma as north-east Scotland theory ruled out". https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/05/origin-stonehenge-altar-remains-enigma-north-east-scotland-ruled-out
  9. Davidson, J. John O'Groat Journal, 11 Nov 2026. "Could Stonehenge Altar Stone really have come from Caithness? Latest research doesn't rule out the possibility". https://www.johnogroat-journal.co.uk/news/could-stonehenge-altar-stone-really-have-come-from-caithness-449939/
  10. Ancient Herald, 10 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's Altar Stone probably did not come from north-east Scotland, new geological study finds". https://ancientherald.com/2026/11/stonehenge-s-altar-stone-probably-did-not-come-from-north-east-scotlan/
  11. de Lazaro, E. Sci.News, 5 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's Altar Stone Still Has No Home, Geologists Say". https://www.sci.news/archaeology/stonehenges-altar-stone-15179.html
  12. ScienceDaily (source: Aberystwyth University), 18 Nov 2026. "Stonehenge's six-ton mystery deepens as scientists narrow their search". http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/11/261117033914.htm

    No comments:

    Post a Comment

    Comments welcome on fresh posts - you just need a Google account to do so.