www.Sarsen.org: Ritual Stones in Scottish Universities

Tuesday, 31 December 2024

Ritual Stones in Scottish Universities

The tradition of "black stone examination" in Scottish universities is a fascinating aspect of academic history, with roots dating back to at least the 16th century. Here's a summary of the references and information about this practice (produced by Perplexity AI agent):

## Origins and Prevalence

The black stone examination was once a common practice among the five ancient Scottish universities. The earliest known reference to this tradition dates back to 1531 at the University of St Andrews[1]. By 1647, the University Commissioners referred to the examination on the "Black-staine" as a practice common to all Scottish universities[1].

## Specific University References

### University of St Andrews

- An "examen quod appellant nigri lapidis" (examination which they call of the black stone) is mentioned in a 1580 regulation[1].

- The reputed black stone of St Andrews University, now in Parliament Hall, appears to be the base of a column[1].

### University of Glasgow

- In 1659, a regulation mentioned that library fees should be paid before a graduand could proceed to "laureation" (graduation) on the black stone[1].

- The University of Glasgow's Blackstone Chair, created in the mid-1770s, incorporated this tradition into a more elaborate piece of furniture[1].

### University of Edinburgh and Marischal College, Aberdeen

- Both institutions once held black stone examinations, although no trace of the stones used survives[1].

### King's College, Aberdeen

- According to one account, the black marble tombstone of the founder, Bishop Elphinstone, was used at graduation[1].

## Nature of the Examination

The black stone examination was typically an oral examination conducted in Latin or Greek. At the University of Glasgow, for example:

- Students sat on the black stone (later, in the Blackstone Chair) while professors tested their knowledge of chosen books[1].

- An hourglass was used to time the examination[1].

- The examination was part of the process for "promotion" to the next stage in the degree structure[1].

## Evolution and Discontinuation

The practice of black stone examination evolved over time:

- At Glasgow, the tradition was incorporated into the elaborate Blackstone Chair in the 1770s[1].

- The Universities Act of 1858 led to the introduction of written examinations, largely ending the practice of oral examinations on the black stone[1].

## Significance

The black stone examination was more than just an academic test; it was a ritual element that added solemnity and tradition to the examination process. Its widespread use across Scottish universities highlights a shared academic culture and tradition unique to Scotland's educational institutions.