The Evolution of the National Heritage Collection Agreement

 English Heritage's licence to operate the Historic England collection of properties has been renewed.

The original 2015 licence is available here:  https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/licence_to_manage_the_national_h

The 2025 one here: https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/renewal_of_english_heritages_lic

A quick analysis by Grok of the changes:

Significant Changes from 2015 to 2025

1. Term and Extension

• 2015 Agreement: The initial term is set at 8 years from the Commencement Date (1 April 2015), ending on 31 March 2023, with no explicit provision for extension beyond this period (Clause 2.1, Definition of "Term"). A two year extension was granted to 2025.
• 2025 Agreement: The initial term is extended to 10 years from the Commencement Date (1 April 2025), ending on 31 March 2035. Additionally, the agreement introduces a mechanism for two potential 5-year extensions, up to a maximum term of 20 years (ending 31 March 2045), subject to mutual agreement before the Extension Confirmation Date (5 years prior to the Term End Date) (Clause 2.4, Definition of "Term End Date").
• Significance: The longer initial term and the option for extensions reflect a shift towards a more sustained partnership, providing the Charity with greater operational stability and planning flexibility.

2. Funding Arrangements

• 2015 Agreement: Includes references to a "Funding Agreement" and a specific "Capital Grant" of £80 million provided to the Charity, indicating structured financial support from the Commission (Definitions, Clause 4.2). These are separate agreements executed alongside the licence.
• 2025 Agreement: Removes references to both the Funding Agreement and the Capital Grant from the definitions and core clauses. Instead, Clause 4.8 introduces a provision where the Commission will "seek funding" from the Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport (DCMS) in specific circumstances (e.g., catastrophic loss, disproportionate expenditure, or to reduce conservation deficits), with no obligation to secure or provide such funding itself.
• Significance: This shift suggests that the initial setup funding has concluded, and the Charity is now expected to be more financially self-sustaining, with funding support becoming contingent and discretionary rather than predefined.

3. Opening Hours Flexibility

• 2015 Agreement: The Charity is required to maintain public opening hours for each Historic Property at no less than 75% of the 2014/15 levels (or 980 hours where unspecified), with reductions needing Commission consent unless due to specific exceptions (e.g., health and safety, repairs) (Clause 5.3).
• 2025 Agreement: Grants the Charity "absolute discretion" over opening hours for individual Historic Properties, provided the total annual opening hours across all Historic Properties do not fall below 75% of the 2023/24 levels (Clause 4.2). The baseline is updated, and the requirement applies collectively rather than per property.
• Significance: The 2025 agreement offers the Charity greater operational flexibility to manage opening hours across the portfolio, adapting to visitor patterns or resource constraints, while still ensuring overall public access.

4. Governance and Oversight

• 2015 Agreement: The Commission can appoint a representative to the Charity’s Board (Clause 40.4), but there are no specific provisions for ongoing attendance or access to board materials beyond general cooperation clauses.
• 2025 Agreement: Enhances Commission oversight significantly:
  • The Commission is entitled to appoint one trustee to the Charity’s Board (Clause 35.1).
  • The Charity must invite the Commission’s Chief Executive to attend trustee meetings as an observer and provide papers to the Chair of the Commission’s Audit and Risk Assurance Committee (Clause 40.4).
  • The Charity’s Chair and Chief Executive must attend Commission trustee meetings when requested to report on performance (Clause 40.5).
• Significance: These changes strengthen the Commission’s influence over the Charity’s governance, ensuring closer alignment with the Commission’s objectives and increased transparency, likely reflecting lessons learned from the initial decade of operation.

5. Insurance Requirements

• 2015 Agreement: Mandates the Charity to maintain building insurance for Historic Properties against risks specified in 'Managing Public Money,' with obligations to reinstate properties using insurance proceeds (Clause 54.1). Additional insurance requires Commission consent aligned with HM Treasury guidance (Clause 55.1).
• 2025 Agreement: Removes the obligation to insure buildings, stating the Charity is "not obliged" to effect building insurance (Clause 47.1). If insurance is taken, conditions apply (e.g., noting Commission interest), but the Charity can self-insure, and there’s no duty to reinstate properties damaged by uninsured risks (Clauses 47.2, 47.4).
• Significance: This relaxation reduces the Charity’s financial burden and aligns with a risk management approach where reinstatement is discretionary, possibly reflecting a reassessment of cost versus benefit after 10 years of operation.

6. Termination Provisions

• 2015 Agreement: Termination is possible for material defaults (remediable or irremediable), insolvency, or force majeure, with a Remediation Plan Process for remediable defaults (Clauses 56, 57). No specific mechanism addresses repeated minor breaches.
• 2025 Agreement: Expands termination grounds:
  • Introduces "Persistent Breach," allowing termination for repeated non-material breaches after a warning notice and final warning notice process (Clauses 48.3, 48.4).
  • Adds a structured dispute resolution process before termination, escalating from legal heads to chief executives, chairs, and potentially DCMS (Clause 65).
• Significance: The Persistent Breach mechanism and dispute resolution process enhance the Commission’s ability to address ongoing issues systematically, balancing fairness with enforceability, and reflect a more mature contractual framework.

7. Data Protection

• 2015 Agreement: Includes basic data protection clauses aligned with the Data Protection Act 1998 (Clause 43), with no detailed schedules or modern compliance frameworks like GDPR.
• 2025 Agreement: Updates to reflect UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018, with a comprehensive Schedule 14 detailing data processing roles, obligations, security, and cross-border transfers (Clause 38, Schedule 14). Emphasizes the Charity’s role in determining Personal Data collection.
• Significance: This update aligns with post-Brexit data protection laws and increased regulatory focus, ensuring robust handling of personal data in line with contemporary standards.

8. Employment Provisions

• 2015 Agreement: Focuses on the initial transfer of employees from the Commission to the Charity (Clause 47), with detailed pension arrangements (Clause 49) and exit provisions for potential future transfers (Clause 48).
• 2025 Agreement: Shifts focus to exit provisions only (Clause 42), detailing employee transfers back to the Commission or a Replacement Operator upon termination, with no mention of initial transfers or pensions, as these were resolved in 2015.
• Significance: The change reflects the completion of the 2015 transition, with the 2025 agreement preparing for potential end-of-term transitions, assuming employment structures are now established.

---

Summary

The transition from the 2015 to the 2025 agreement marks a maturation of the partnership between the Commission and the Charity. Key changes include a longer and extendable term, a move away from fixed funding to discretionary support, increased operational flexibility (e.g., opening hours, insurance), stronger Commission oversight in governance, and updates to reflect legal developments (e.g., Brexit, GDPR). These adjustments suggest a relationship that has evolved from an initial setup phase to one focused on sustainability, adaptability, and refined accountability after a decade of experience.