Saturday, 21 November 2026

Neolithic Visibility of Avenue Stripes

Matthew Canti’s debate piece in Antiquity asks whether the grooves under the Stonehenge Avenue, if they are solstice-aligned periglacial stripes, could have been seen before about 3000 BC. His answer is no: “the stripes could not have been seen without removal of the topsoil” (Canti 2026, 1). He states that the solstice interpretation “is necessarily dependent on the stripes having been visible” (Canti 2026, 1). It is not. Allen et al. suggested two ways the alignment might have been noticed: the parallel ridges “as earthworks”, and the stripes “as areas of lusher vegetation” over the deeper soil in the fissures (Allen et al. 2016, 997). Canti cites that paper for the vegetation, and places the parchmark claim correctly on later work (Parker Pearson and Pullen 2020, 418), but he does not deal with the ridges. If the ridges were natural and stood proud, the alignment was visible whatever the stripes did. Mike Pitts has responded in detail (Pitts 2026). What follows looks at both parts of the hypothesis from the soil side: the stripes, where Canti’s case is weaker than it looks, and the ridges, which his paper leaves untouched.

Parchmarks

Canti’s argument is partly mechanistic and partly from the record. The mechanism: “the porous nature of both the silty infilling and the surrounding chalk offer little chance for the differentiation of moisture retention” needed to yellow one zone and not the other, and any difference would need “an even, short-grass sward” to show against (Canti 2026, 4). The record: “stripes have never (to the author’s knowledge) been recorded as parchmarks at the surface” (Canti 2026, 5).

The mechanistic half does not hold at Stonehenge itself. In July 2013, stoneholes cut into the same chalk, under the same short turf, showed clearly as parchmarks, the grass over them browning before the grass around them (Banton et al. 2014). A backfilled stonehole is not a Devensian silt stripe, and the contrast need not run the same way: Allen et al. (2016) expected lusher growth over the deeper fissure fill. What 2013 shows is that a contrast between fill and chalk can reach the surface through thin turf, which is what Canti’s argument from porosity denies. Chalk supplies water to shallow roots by capillary rise through moderate dry spells; contrasts appear when a severe drought breaks that supply, which is why parchmarks on chalk are episodic.

The record looks like the stronger half of Canti’s case. The stretch of Avenue beyond the Heel Stone is among the most photographed ground in Britain, through the droughts of 2013, 2018, 2022 and 2026, the last captured in Google Earth imagery (Google Earth 2026). But the record is weaker than it looks. Canti’s own condition for seeing a parchmark is “an even, short-grass sward” (Canti 2026, 4), and the Avenue does not provide one. Mowing patterns, vehicle tracks and the paths worn by visitors and staff cross it in every direction, and each produces its own differential parching. A faint, regular stripe pattern would have to show through that overprint. The absence of recorded stripes is therefore inconclusive. It counts against visibility only weakly, and for it not at all. Canti’s wider point, that stripes are not recorded as parchmarks on chalk grassland elsewhere, is untouched by this and remains in his favour.

The ridges

The ridges are the half of the hypothesis that Canti does not address. Allen et al. offer no soil or vegetation data from the Avenue for them; the case that they would have been noticed rests on their present visibility as earthworks for about 150 m from the Heel Stone (Allen et al. 2016, 995). Parker Pearson’s own first reading in the field was that the banks had protected the chalk beneath them while the surface around was weathered down. He rejects that on several grounds: the ridges are absent at the Avenue bend, where the ditches, and so presumably the banks, were no smaller; they stand up to about 0.5 m, a rise matched elsewhere only under the Stonehenge enclosure bank, whose ditch produced three times the spoil; the wheel ruts in Trench 45 lie well above bedrock and cannot have lowered it; the ground between the banks is no lower than the ground outside the ditches; and the ridges belong to a corrugated surface some 210 m long and up to 45 m wide, with hollows outside the Avenue as well as within it (Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 469–72).

Those arguments are strong, but they leave the origin of the ridges open. Pitts notes that in the published sections “the surviving ground with wheel ruts and periglacial features is lower than the chalk under the banks. If that higher chalk is a natural feature, why does it not have any periglacial disturbances?” (Pitts 2026). Parker Pearson concedes that “exactly how the geomorphological features were formed remains something of a mystery” (Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 472). The soil evidence from beneath the banks is slight. Under the western bank in Trench 45, Charles French recorded a rendzina “approximately 19cm thick”, its turf “most probably truncated during the construction of the Avenue bank”; under the eastern bank only 9–10 cm survived, the lower third of a rendzina (French, in Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 429–30). Two small exposures cannot show whether the chalk beneath the banks is a natural crest.

Either way, the ridges matter more to the solstice hypothesis than the stripes do. If they are natural, as Allen et al. and Parker Pearson argue, they formed a solstice-aligned landform that could be seen before the Avenue was built, whatever the stripes did, and Canti’s conclusion does not reach it. If they are not, the alignment had no visible expression in the landform, and the stripes are all that remain to be tested.

Vegetation bands and sour soils

Canti accepts that vegetation stripes occur where involution juxtaposes materials with “substantially different rooting and growth conditions”, as at Grimes Graves, where acid coversand alternates with chalk, but says this “could not have occurred in the Stonehenge area due to the lack of the acidic sand” (Canti 2026, 5). The Avenue has no coversand, and no heather-and-grass pattern of the Breckland kind is in question. But sand is not the operative variable. The contrast needed is one of base status and rooting depth within the root zone, and on the Wiltshire chalk that contrast has been supplied by decalcified silt and drift.

Thomas Davis divided the native soil of the Downs into “the red land” and “the black land” (Davis 1811, 107). The red land of the high downs, much of it formerly wooded, was “wood-sour land” (111–12), and chalk was applied at “160 cart-loads on an acre” (111–12) as “a corrector of land that has acidity in it” (111). The red land would bear chalking; the black land of the valley sides and slopes “seldom or never” (108), yet heath grew on many parts of the black land, which Davis put down to light stocking rather than poor ground.

Neither of Davis’s categories quite fits a third soil of the high downs: the black, puffy, acid topsoil of summits such as Tan Hill. These are humic rendzinas of the Icknield type, a dark, organic, silt-rich surface horizon resting directly on chalk (LandIS). Shallow as they are, they can be decalcified through their full depth. At Overton Down, near Avebury, the Ah horizon averages 18 cm, is up to 53 per cent silt, partly late Devensian loess, and is decalcified to the point that land snails are essentially absent (Bell et al. 1996; Macphail et al., online appendix 4.1). Chalk heath survives today at Porton Down, about ten kilometres south-east of the Avenue. None of this places acid soil on the Avenue spur, which looks more like Davis’s black land of the slopes. It does show that pH and soil depth varied sharply across the Wiltshire chalk, and that an acid surface needs neither coversand nor deep drift: 18 cm of leached loessic silt over chalk is enough. Canti’s reliance on coversand alone does not allow for that.

The more relevant point is the soil that existed before about 3000 BC. Micromorphology from the Stonehenge Riverside Project found a predominance of very fine sand and coarse silt, suggesting a loessic input, in every soil profile examined, and relict argillic brown earths, decalcified and probably former woodland soils, surviving in tree-throw hollows and under some later banks (French et al. 2012). The buried soil under the western Avenue bank is itself 30–40 per cent very fine sand and coarse silt, which French reads as a substantial loessic component (French, in Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 430). On John Evans’s model, the early Holocene soil on this chalk was a leached brown earth that clearance and mixing later turned into a rendzina. A stripe pattern with decalcified silt in the troughs and chalk at shallow depth on the ridges would give exactly the difference in rooting conditions that Canti requires. That remains a possibility, not an observation: Allen and French describe stripe fills on the Wiltshire chalk as “often filled with silty calcareous deposits” (Allen and French, in Parker Pearson et al. 2020, 430), and the Trench 45 fissures held “clean, beige-coloured silt” (Allen et al. 2016, 992). The Trench 45 soil, sealed when the bank was built in 2500–2270 cal BC (Allen et al. 2016, 1004), does not settle this: it shows the surface six centuries after the date that matters.

The land snails point the same way. At Overton Down their absence is itself the mark of decalcification. At the Avenue bend, Evans found the ditch deposits “often weakly calcareous or decalcified” and their molluscan content “generally poor” (Evans 1984, 24). The two ditches differed: the south-east ditch was filled with non-calcareous, flinty clay loam, while the north-west ditch was calcareous throughout and was the only one that could be sampled for snails. Calcareous and decalcified fills therefore lie about 22 m apart, across the Avenue itself. Under the western bank in Trench 45 the buried soil is a rendzina (French et al. 2012), but on the A303 route east of Stonehenge a rare prehistoric decalcified argillic brown earth survives under colluvium (Macphail and Crowther, in Leivers and Moore 2008). Base status varied across the width of the Avenue itself; whether it also varied at the scale of individual stripes, here fissures 0.4 m wide and 0.5 m deep (Allen et al. 2016, 992), is what an excavated section would show.

Stripe patterns certainly express at the surface on thinly drift-covered chalk. Robert Evans, of the Soil Survey, described “a stripe pattern seen on air photographs” on such ground “from the East Riding of Yorkshire to Wiltshire” (Evans 1976), and Canti’s own Figure 4 shows large stripes on a ploughed chalk and coversand surface in Kent. These are arable cases, where the plough brings the contrast into the topsoil, and so are consistent with Canti’s exception rather than a refutation of it. What they show is that the contrast is there in the subsoil to be expressed.

Paring and burning

The modern downland soil is also a product of historic agriculture. Paring and burning, in Wiltshire burn-beaking or denshiring, stripped the turf, burned it and spread the ash to take a few crops from the downs. Aubrey records that Mr Bishop of Merton (Martin) first brought it into south Wiltshire about 1639: “they say ’tis good for the father, but naught for the son, by reason it does so weare out the heart of the land” (Aubrey 1847, 103). Davis records that the black land, once broken up by burn-beaking, was reduced within a few crops “to a mere bed of dust” (Davis 1811, 108), and that it “should by no means be broken up” (109).

The practice is documented around Stonehenge. In Durrington, 11 acres of the Rectory down had been burnbaked by 1684; in 1740 the commoners agreed to burnbake 12 acres of down near the Shrewton boundary; and part of a West End manor down was “occasionally burnbaked” in 1776 (VCH Wilts. xv, 100). In Winterbourne Stoke, small areas of downland were brought into cultivation by burnbaking between about 1600 and 1800 (VCH Wilts. xv, 281). The barrow-studded ground now under the northern part of Fargo Plantation, north-west of Stonehenge, was converted to arable as burnbake, perhaps in the eighteenth century (Bishop 2011, 10, 28–9), and Rollestone Bake Farm, on the same downs, carried that name by 1899 (VCH Wilts. xi, 209, 211).

The soil consequences are specific. Paring removes the humic A horizon; burning destroys the organic matter and releases its bases, so the ash acts as a short-lived lime and potash dressing; the cropping that follows leaves a bare, structureless surface open to wind and rain. On shallow chalk the end product is the thin, stony, calcareous profile Davis describes. No record places burnbake on the Avenue itself, but the downs around it were pared, burned and ploughed in historic times. The thin rendzina sealed under the Avenue bank shows that clearance and grazing had already thinned the soil by about 2400 BC; burn-beaking and ploughing compounded that. Canti’s “0.1–0.2m of uniform, worm-sorted topsoil” (Canti 2026, 4–5) is the end of that long sequence, not its starting point.

What would settle it

Canti’s case rests on two assumptions, neither measured at the Avenue: that the pre-3000 BC soil was a uniform, worm-sorted cover of 0.1–0.2 m, and that silty fill and chalk offer no usable contrast in water or base status. The first describes the soil after millennia of clearance, grazing and cultivation. The second is contradicted by the stonehole parchmarks of 2013. Against that, the only soil sealed beneath the Avenue is calcareous, and aerial coverage, though it has not shown the stripes, is taken over a surface too disturbed to test the question.

More fundamentally, Canti answers only half the hypothesis. If the ridges are natural, the alignment was visible in the landform whatever the stripes did, and his conclusion leaves the solstice argument where it was.

Further photography of the most photographed monument in Britain will not resolve it. Excavation could. A section through bank-sealed ground across both a trough and a ridge would record whether the buried soil changes in thickness, carbonate content, pH and fabric from one to the other, and would show whether the chalk under the bank is a natural crest. If the buried A horizon is uniform across the stripes, Canti is right for the surface of about 2400 BC, though not necessarily for the six centuries before it. If it is thicker, darker or decalcified over the troughs, the stripes had a surface expression after all.

References

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments welcome on fresh posts - you just need a Google account to do so.